• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Limited Slip and Gears

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
As many of y’all have seen in my other threads, a sim me bearing replacement has turned into a full on rear end rebuild. So I thought I would start another thread to clear up some of my questions and to ask for advice.

I have 35s with a 3.5” SL and a narrowed HP D44 going in the front.

1. I am planning on going with a limited slip carrier and 4.56 gears in the rear and then locking the front. My Bronco is going to be mostly street mild trail (for now). Thoughts on this setup?

2. My axle tag shows a 8.7” ring gear. Will I have any problems with swapping that over to a full 9” limited slip with the 4.56s?

3. I plan on getting one of the third member rebuild kits from the vendors as well as the gears. And then taking it to a shop to have it put in.

4. Pinion yolk. Upgrade? Leave stock? Anything else I should do to that area while I’m in there?

5. Spider gears? Does the limited slip unit completely take the place of the spider gear setup or how does that work? If not should I be looking to rebuild/ upgrade while in there?

6. Lastly, advice or thoughts or things to watch out for while doing this. Please feel free to explain it like I’m five. I’m learning as I go here.

Long story short I’m building a street/mild trail rig that I want to overbuild slightly for that application. The first part I’m tackling is the rear ended

Pics attached because everyone likes pics.
06d77d09ab70972fb10b4ff89ccfe0a8.jpg
f9afe58c0e8cbb3fd9c702dac42dbd72.jpg
2941ab4154f5545f938ae556c8b37b0a.jpg
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
1) not a fan of rear limited slips. Sort of the worst of both worlds. In the rain and slick the back will want to step out as if it were locked, but when you need it to be locked it will peg leg like an open. A locker in the front can really fight you for steering, a nice torque biasing limited slip generally works better up front.

2) No problem. There might need to be a little cleaning up around the pinion support (remove excess material) due to the gear ratio. But a 9" ring gear will fit just fine

3) The shop may not appreciate it. If the parts don't work together they are now fighting you and your vender. That is time they are not getting paid for. Any decent gear shop will be getting better prices for install kits than you will you will be getting. They may charge you a little more for it, but that is part of there profit. It is not uncommon for a shop to charge more to install customer supplied parts, if they are even willing to do it. Unless you already talked to the shop and this is what they told you to do, don't plan on doing it this way.

4) Are you cranking up the HP to require upgraded parts? Not enough info but guessing that stock will be fine.

5) Most differentials will still have some sort of spider gears. But they are specific to that limited slip/locker design. You will not be using your old ones. The new differential you get will have new stuff in it. Noting to worry about.

6) are you going to 31 spline axles at the same time?
6.1) do just the rear axle at first. Go test drive it. Hate the ratio, you are only regearing one axle. So much better than paying to regear 2 axles. Once you like the rear, gear the front to match.
 
OP
OP
Okie69

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
Thanks for the detailed reply!

1) Well dang, I've been thinking lockers this whole time but for a street/ mild wheeling rig what I've read seems to be pointing towards a limited slip. opinions on a better direction?

3) the shop I am working with is not a dedicated gear shop or anything. It's an old timer that builds drag cars and has a couple of employees. I've had him do a couple of other things and he always had me bring all the components.

4) short story yes, after a rebuild that ill probably last a couple of years the end goal is a heated up stroker or 351. I'm trying to future proof for that possibility.

6) I'm looking for a consensus. If the 28 spline will hold up to what I'm doing then I'll stick with them. If I need to go 31s then i guess this is the time to do it. But i wonder what the real benefit is since I will still be running the small bearing ends.

6.1) that is the plan for sure. I don't even have the old D30 pulled out yet. (that's the next part of the build. I guess Ishould've mentioned I'm trying to stick with the 3 speed on the column for now. It's pretty much a dog with the 35s and 3.50s right now.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Personally, I say NEVER NEVER NEVER run a locker while keeping your 28 spline axles.
You may never break one, but there are just WAYYYY toooo many reports of busted shafts with lockers installed. Frankly, some of those reports were even on the street! So if that ain't enough to put the big question mark over your head, not much will.
Add the 35" tires, and your axles are just living on borrowed time!!!!

Not even sure you can get a 28-spline Detroit anymore, and you haven't been able to get a 28-spline ARB for more than twenty years now.
For the very reason of busted axle shafts.

And almost never keep 28's if you're already paying the extra for just a limited slip diff either. Yes, many of us have done it, including me for awhile. No busted axles. But it's just not worth the savings in a couple-hundred bucks for new axles to lose sleep over.
And if you do, then you just need to spend more money on an even newer differential later, when you do upgrade to 31 spline axles.

I get it though. With your very mild intended use, you may very well be perfectly happy with stock axle shafts. But I still come back to the big tires and the future big power engine, then keep coming back to the need for stronger axles.
I just can't get away from that.

The whole reason 31 spline axles have been one of the first go-to upgrades for literally the last 40 years, is that once Broncos started getting bigger tires and going off-road more, those with even the factory installed limited-slips were breaking axle shafts far too often.
I say if you're going to stick with stock axles and just going to do mild stuff, then just keep the open differential too. Traction diffs are just unnecessary bling based on what others rave about, for at least 80% of Bronco owners.
How many members here have done serious Sierra trails, including the Rubicon with just stock open diffs? A lot of us I bet.

I say forget a full locker in the rear of a street rig, even if you do want to go off road with it now and then. It's just not worth the expense and trouble it can cause on the street in spite of what some diehards say.
It's not from breaking axles in this case (because you would already have 31's) but from a drivability standpoint.
It's not always unsafe of course, and I drive around with a Detroit in the back of mine now, but don't let anyone tell you you can't feel a locker in the back of a lifted, short-wheelbase rig like ours. You can.
And on rare occasions, it is in fact unsafe and now and then completely un-drivable. Had one friend that had to change his out for something milder, and another friend is coming over soon to let me drive his to find out why it's so squirelly on the street. I know already, but will drive it anyway.

If you just have to have the occasional security of a locker, get a selectable like an ARB.
But there goes your whole budget right out the window!

1) Well dang, I've been thinking lockers this whole time but for a street/ mild wheeling rig what I've read seems to be pointing towards a limited slip. opinions on a better direction?

Sure. Leave it open, like 80% of Broncos out there used to be.

4) short story yes, after a rebuild that ill probably last a couple of years the end goal is a heated up stroker or 351. I'm trying to future proof for that possibility.

Then forget building around 28 spline axles and spend the extra 250-350 now and not have to change out your whole diff later to accommodate 31 spline axles. Do it right, do it once.

6) I'm looking for a consensus.

No such thing.

If the 28 spline will hold up to what I'm doing then I'll stick with them. If I need to go 31s then i guess this is the time to do it. But i wonder what the real benefit is since I will still be running the small bearing ends.

Now we're back to the small bearing ends, which is a subject unto itself.
Has very little to do with the axles snap anyway. With limited-slips and lockers the breaks are usually in at the diff's side gears. 31 spline axles are just bigger back inside there. Sure, it's possible that you will create a new "weak link" out at the wheel bearings by upgrading to 31. And it's not like nobody has ever broken one out at the bearing before, but with small bearings I would not go 31's anyway because you're spending way too much now, for the changes you will be making later if you're going to ultimately go with a big bearing housing and throw away your brand new heavy duty axles and special expensive bearings anyway.

If you need to go that route, stick with all stock for now, just change the gears to what you want, then build an entirely new housing with axle shafts and diff later as budget allows.

A rear diff in a multi-purpose Bronco is a snowball waiting to happen as you're finding out. It's the famed rabbit hole of money pits.
If you really want the best bang-for-the-buck in reliability, just change your gears now and then build up an entirely new large bearing housing piece by piece with all the goodies.
But still forget the lockers unless you're spending way more time off-road than you expected, or put more power to the wheels than intended, or decide you want to be a teenager again (hey, it happens!) and grow back your really heavy right foot for doing burnouts, donuts and rock jumping.;D

Paul
 
OP
OP
Okie69

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
So ,based on input...

Revised proposed plan.

4.56 gears in a 31 spline open carrier (will I need to purchase new spider gear set separately? if so 2 pinion vs 4 pinion?)

31 spline shafts that will come with bearings and seals.

This will get me back on the road with the added security of a stronger rear end for the eventual increase in power and torque I'm planning on. Then when the day (And funds) come for a serious upgrade go big bearing housing fully built with a selectable locker.
 

Nothing Special

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2016
Messages
848
I generally agree with everything Paul said. I have a Detroit in my rear axle because I rock crawl. And I really I don't mind it on the street. I've even daily-driven a CJ5 with a rear Detroit in the winter. The shorter, narrower Jeep makes the Detroits quirks even more apparent, and snow or ice is where it'll bite you the hardest. But saying that, I wouldn't put up with an automatic locker in the rear except for the fact that I really value it on the trail.

I'm not a fan of clutch-type limited slips at all. Winter driving is a fact of life for me, and even pretty loose limited slips will spin you out when coasting around a corner. Automatic lockers are a handful when you get on the gas too hard, but that's in your control. Clutch-type limited slips are always trying to scrub tires. And as Broncobowsher said, they usually aren't tight enough when you do need them.

I thought I'd really like the Truetrac, but now that I'm in my second winter with one in my pickup I'm less of a fan. It's a lot better than a clutch-type limited slip because it doesn't try to spin you out when coasting. But while it's a lot smoother than an automatic locker, you do have to be almost as careful with the throttle in snow. And while it's better than an open diff, in practice it's not really that much better. By that I mean it's kind of rare that I'm in conditions where I would need 4WD with an open rear diff but can get by in 2WD with the Truetrac. It does give better traction than an open diff, just not enough better for me to say I'm a huge fan. If I was doing it again I might, but I might just save the money too.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Revised proposed plan...

Not out of line, but I would add that you can now consider keeping the 28 spline axles, simply because you also opted to stick with the open diff for now.
Since you're staying open, the axles are not under near as much stress, even with the 35's. And buying the more expensive 31-spline version now (it's only 75 bucks more than the big bearing versions, but hey, it's still "more"), and then not being able to use them when you swap to your traction diff in the new housing, I'd be more likely to just save that extra $325 now, and put it towards the new stuff later.

As I think we talked about in another thread, it's not out of line to do what you propose, because you'll still have a nice old small bearing housing and nice new-ish HD axles to sell up to the next person and get some of your money back after you build your big diff.
But really, when it comes down to it, given your expected use for the near future, are you really needing the 31 spline axles while you're still running an open diff?

In spite of what it may have sounded like I said previously, upgrading to the new axles even with the small bearing housing was as much about using a traction diff than anything else. Keeping the diff open reduces the need for 31-splines enough (even with the larger tires) that I would consider them overkill unless you decide you're going to do a lot of four-wheeling after all.
I'd be singing a different tune if you were also upgrading your diff to a limited-slip right now. But you're not, so the 28 vs 31 argument is much softer at this point.

New 31 spline side gears for the open diff are super cheap (or used to be anyway) so that's not even an issue, but buying axles you don't really need and can't use in your next build is simply lower on the desirability checklist in my book.

Just one more thing to think about during all this.%)
I'm a little on the fence of course, knowing how nice it feels to have upgraded parts in the diff when you're out even on a mild trail.
Just trying to give you a head start to the next build!
Of course, the new lower gearing might give you that tingly feeling and you could be romping on the gas more than normal too!

Sorry for all the added confusion, but wanting you to have all the lined up ducks straight in your head when you plunk down your money.

Paul
 

bax

Contributor
Old Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2005
Messages
14,552
as usual, Paul is loaded with the good advice. It sounds to me like you might benefit from the suffer, save and spend option. The 3 S's. Suffer thru with what ever works. find some used parts that will get you rolling. Save up, This is very hard to do with a bronco in the garage. But like most of us there are other bills that need to be paid. Spend! your money one time on good parts. It's easier to say, harder to do.
Good luck. I have a dana 30 with a factory track lock and a 4.11 gear. Complete hub to hub. If it helps you can have it. ( I have had it 15 years offered to many people but no one wants it). Cheap front end with a decent gear. You will break it if you dont take it easy. I also have a posi 28 spline 9'' carrier. You can have it too. Now all you need to find is a gear. you'r getting closer to the save portion of the show. save while you suffer with the used equipment.
Just trying to help.
Bax
 

matt w

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
2,799
I am like you.
I wanted something that was trail worthy but didn’t want to bash it on the rocks out here in California. I wanted a truck that I could drive at 70 with all my camping gear and go To 98% of where I wanted to go without going on the “extreme” trails.
With that said I too have 33’s and 4:56 gears. While I was doing the lift I pulled the t-case and did a Tera-Low gear reduction so that I could go slower in low and not beat the truck or me up when coming to challenges. I have a limited slip in the rear end and it really works VERY WELL.
I also installed a front e-locker which makes the truck MORE THAN CAPABLE!
I added a twin stick as well with a heavy duty output shaft.
To look at my bronco it just doesn’t seem all that BUT IT CAN CLIMB AND FLEXES like a madman! I even had to cut just a bit more of the rear old school fiberglass flares that were on it and a lot of the “inner fender” sharp metal I. The front and back but other than that it looks stock with a 3.5 lift...

I dont know what type of off roading you will be doing BUT the lower transfer case and twin sticks for me is a “must have” and adding that front e-locker is the icing on the cake!

Good Luck in your continued build!
All the best,
Matt w.
 
OP
OP
Okie69

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
Not out of line, but I would add that you can now consider keeping the 28 spline axles, simply because you also opted to stick with the open diff for now.
Since you're staying open, the axles are not under near as much stress, even with the 35's. And buying the more expensive 31-spline version now (it's only 75 bucks more than the big bearing versions, but hey, it's still "more"), and then not being able to use them when you swap to your traction diff in the new housing, I'd be more likely to just save that extra $325 now, and put it towards the new stuff later.

Yep, I forgot that the axles for this housing won't work with the big bearing version later.

Does the recommendation change if I plan on putting a stronger motor in? Right now I'm out an engine and will probably be upgrading.
 
OP
OP
Okie69

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
as usual, Paul is loaded with the good advice. It sounds to me like you might benefit from the suffer, save and spend option. The 3 S's. Suffer thru with what ever works. find some used parts that will get you rolling. Save up, This is very hard to do with a bronco in the garage. But like most of us there are other bills that need to be paid. Spend! your money one time on good parts. It's easier to say, harder to do.
Good luck. I have a dana 30 with a factory track lock and a 4.11 gear. Complete hub to hub. If it helps you can have it. ( I have had it 15 years offered to many people but no one wants it). Cheap front end with a decent gear. You will break it if you dont take it easy. I also have a posi 28 spline 9'' carrier. You can have it too. Now all you need to find is a gear. you'r getting closer to the save portion of the show. save while you suffer with the used equipment.
Just trying to help.
Bax

Wow that super generous! I'm pretty set on the front end but that posi rear is intriguing. I'm in OK where are you located? I assume we would have to ship it.
 
OP
OP
Okie69

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
I’m still trying to decide a direction. My big worry is breaking stuff just driving around town.

I’m going to be getting the blueprint Bronco motor that I’m sure everyone has seen. It’s rated at 365/365

Can I build up my small bearing 9 to handle
It, or do I just need to start looking for a big bearing housing?
 

.94 OR

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
2,215
Loc.
Willamette Valley, OR
As you have read, I did this same calculation last summer/fall.

I had a spare small bearing housing that I cleaned up and installed longer spring perches so I could move the axle back 1" to center in the wheel opening and added a rear truss just for fun. I am still not convinced that I will ever wear out or damage the small bearing housing or the bearings on the 31 spline conversion axles that I elected to go with. I simply don't drive it enough or hard enough to exceed their strength. Like you, I plan to add more power than stock so the center section was upgraded with a recommendation from Yukon as the small bearing third member was only rated to 200 hp according to the Yukon rep. I was fortunate to find a used Yukon zip-locker/ARB pump with plumbing for a good price so I went that route for mine. I have a factory limited slip in the D44 with has worked good for my uses in the past so I'm looking forward to using mine as is, and having more power in the future as I'm looking forward to your reviews of the 306 Bronco engine.
 
OP
OP
Okie69

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
As you have read, I did this same calculation last summer/fall.



I had a spare small bearing housing that I cleaned up and installed longer spring perches so I could move the axle back 1" to center in the wheel opening and added a rear truss just for fun. I am still not convinced that I will ever wear out or damage the small bearing housing or the bearings on the 31 spline conversion axles that I elected to go with. I simply don't drive it enough or hard enough to exceed their strength. Like you, I plan to add more power than stock so the center section was upgraded with a recommendation from Yukon as the small bearing third member was only rated to 200 hp according to the Yukon rep. I was fortunate to find a used Yukon zip-locker/ARB pump with plumbing for a good price so I went that route for mine. I have a factory limited slip in the D44 with has worked good for my uses in the past so I'm looking forward to using mine as is, and having more power in the future as I'm looking forward to your reviews of the 306 Bronco engine.



When you say upgraded center section do you mean the ring and pinion or the locker or both? I’m still deciding on what to do for traction devices and am leaning towards going with an open diff (as per recommendations) to try to keep the small bearing rear in one piece.

I was under the impression that the differences between the small and large bearing variants were all on the axle ends ie brakes and bearing sizes. I know there are 31 spline vs 28 spline differences in the center. Is this not the case?
 

.94 OR

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
2,215
Loc.
Willamette Valley, OR
For me, the center section is the cast iron third member.

The jump from the 28 to 31 spline axle has is a remarkable size increase visually and I'm sure a significant jump in engineered strength. When I was about 20 I let the rear end have too much power and I blew the factory LS apart so I knew there is a power limit to these components.

You can see the Strange center section (3.06" bearing) is quite a bit beefier round the bearing cradles over the factory small bearing (2.89" bearing) set up.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5287.jpg
    IMG_5287.jpg
    111.6 KB · Views: 79
  • IMG_5291.jpg
    IMG_5291.jpg
    115.3 KB · Views: 91
  • IMG_5292.jpg
    IMG_5292.jpg
    89.3 KB · Views: 81
OP
OP
Okie69

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
Oh wow yeah that’s a big difference.

So you’re running a small bearing house but with the 31 spline conversion on the axle
ends and this beefier setup for the third member?

Info on that third member? You may have just solved my worries.
 

.94 OR

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 5, 2009
Messages
2,215
Loc.
Willamette Valley, OR
This is what I ended up doing, but this just fit my needs with only a 31" tire and 3.50 gears. Someday I may end up with 33's but no plans at this time.

Price has gone up a couple bucks since I bought mine, but still a decent price in my mind.
Strange center section:

https://www.summitracing.com/parts/str-n2205/overview/

Bearing kit:

https://www.quickperformance.com/Ford-9-Master-Bearing--Install-Kit-Timken-USA_p_13.html

Axles:

https://www.tomsbroncoparts.com/pro...10-drums-2-78-bearing-66-75-early-ford-bronco

You might browse around the Quick Performance site to see if they have anything that interests you.
 
OP
OP
Okie69

Okie69

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2011
Messages
842
This is what I ended up doing, but this just fit my needs with only a 31" tire and 3.50 gears. Someday I may end up with 33's but no plans at this time.



Price has gone up a couple bucks since I bought mine, but still a decent price in my mind.

Strange center section:



https://www.summitracing.com/parts/str-n2205/overview/



Bearing kit:



https://www.quickperformance.com/Ford-9-Master-Bearing--Install-Kit-Timken-USA_p_13.html



Axles:



https://www.tomsbroncoparts.com/pro...10-drums-2-78-bearing-66-75-early-ford-bronco



You might browse around the Quick Performance site to see if they have anything that interests you.



Thank you for the replies sir!
 
Top