• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Surprise under valvecover

OP
OP
ribbits

ribbits

Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
130
It does look bent in the pic. but doesn't look that way in person.. I guess I need to figure a way to check it in place because it won't budge.. How hard should it be to push the valve down? Can I force it open a little while pushing down on it with like a block of wood or something? I tried once and couldn't budge it either?
 

tirewater

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
1,046
Loc.
San Francisco Bay Area
If everything seems fine, put it back together and make sure the nuts are tightened properly. I wouldn't go any tighter than spec. The nuts can split if tightened too much.

If you have the same cylinder head as my truck, it's 3/8" studs that use 5/16" nuts. Double check to make sure before buying new nuts.
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
just put the rocker back on and turn the engine over then you can watch the valve open and close or make a tool out of a piece of flat bar that you can put on the rocker stud and use to lever the valve down.
I'm more in agreement that you may have a sticking valve. I'm not totally on board that its todays gas as lead was not used to lube the valve guides valve seats yes but not the guides. I think its more of a issue with engines that don't get run for long periods of time. My 71 bends a pushrod or two every time I start it. I need to pull those heads as I'm out of spare pushrods.
On the other hand it could be the cam being a bit to big for the setup. Need to check and make sure the rocker arm is not touching the valve retainer when its fully open. Also make sure the rails are not touching the retainer or keepers at full lift. Might be a good idea to check pushrod length. aftermarket cams and rail rockers don't mix well. In the end Id consider either getting the heads setup for adjustable rockers or getting some aftermarket heads already setup. Not sure what the prices are nowadays but I was going to get some stock heads setup the way I wanted and the cost was only $1-200 below what aftermarkets cost and the aftermarkets are better out of the box than the stock heads would ever be even with a few hundred dollars more work into them.
 
OP
OP
ribbits

ribbits

Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
130
just put the rocker back on and turn the engine over then you can watch the valve open and close or make a tool out of a piece of flat bar that you can put on the rocker stud and use to lever the valve down.
I'm more in agreement that you may have a sticking valve. I'm not totally on board that its todays gas as lead was not used to lube the valve guides valve seats yes but not the guides. I think its more of a issue with engines that don't get run for long periods of time. My 71 bends a pushrod or two every time I start it. I need to pull those heads as I'm out of spare pushrods.
On the other hand it could be the cam being a bit to big for the setup. Need to check and make sure the rocker arm is not touching the valve retainer when its fully open. Also make sure the rails are not touching the retainer or keepers at full lift. Might be a good idea to check pushrod length. aftermarket cams and rail rockers don't mix well. In the end Id consider either getting the heads setup for adjustable rockers or getting some aftermarket heads already setup. Not sure what the prices are nowadays but I was going to get some stock heads setup the way I wanted and the cost was only $1-200 below what aftermarkets cost and the aftermarkets are better out of the box than the stock heads would ever be even with a few hundred dollars more work into them.

Will definitely look into that regarding heads,, didn't know that was possible... Much obliged !
 
OP
OP
ribbits

ribbits

Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
130
If everything seems fine, put it back together and make sure the nuts are tightened properly. I wouldn't go any tighter than spec. The nuts can split if tightened too much.

If you have the same cylinder head as my truck, it's 3/8" studs that use 5/16" nuts. Double check to make sure before buying new nuts.

Yep...same ones..thanks
 

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
...it had nothing like 20 ft lbs of torque on it...
That's what happens when the cam comes up, and the pushrod is out of its socket because the rocker stayed down on the stuck valve - the pushrod is effectively too long, so that force goes against the stud & nut instead of the valve spring, and it stretches too little to see, but enough to relieve some of the torque.
I laid a machine tool straight edge across the top of both the adjacent studs and it doesn't appear to be any longer than those...
That means it didn't come out of the head (or stretch) nearly enough to have been the root cause of the pushrod falling out-of-place. It had to be a sticky valve.
even a stuck lifter could have caused this valve to jump track.
Stuck where? At the top of the cam lobe? That would simply have held the valve open, and the pushrod would have stayed in-place. At the bottom? That would have wiped the cam lobe, broken the camshaft between that lobe & the gear, or stopped the engine. But all of that pushrod's, rocker's, & valve's movement comes from the lifter - if the lifter sticks (anywhere), that pushrod/rocker/valve would have just stayed in-place. So that can't be what happened.

It has to have been a stuck valve. Since the stud is in-position, the valve is the only thing that could have relieved enough of the spring's load from the pushrod for it to come out of its socket in the rocker.
How hard should it be to push the valve down?
When it's NOT stuck, and the spring is in-place: too hard for you to do by hand, even with all your weight. If you use a spring compressor, and remove the keepers: the valve should drop into the cylinder under its own weight (assuming you aren't preventing it from doing so). With the spring & keepers in-place, tapping it with a medium-sized hammer (not a tack hammer, and not a BFH) should cause it to barely open & close faster than you can see. But it will look, sound, & feel distinctly different from tapping on a rocker stud, so you can compare it to that.

But if it's sticky, it will look, sound, & feel very similar to the stud; or it may delay closing long enough for you to notice that it didn't come back up at the same time as the hammer; or it may just stay down & each hammer tap will push it down slightly more, until there's enough spring compression to slam it shut.

Those tests will cost you NOTHING but a few minutes, and then you'll KNOW what happened. How you fix it is your choice, but a fuel additive is a cheap test while you're saving nickels for new heads.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
ribbits

ribbits

Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
130
That's what happens when the cam comes up, and the pushrod is out of its socket because the rocker stayed down on the stuck valve - the pushrod is effectively too long, so that force goes against the stud & nut instead of the valve spring, and it stretches too little to see, but enough to relieve some of the torque.That means it didn't come out of the head (or stretch) nearly enough to have been the root cause of the pushrod falling out-of-place. It had to be a sticky valve.Stuck where? At the top of the cam lobe? That would simply have held the valve open, and the pushrod would have stayed in-place. At the bottom? That would have wiped the cam lobe, broken the camshaft between that lobe & the gear, or stopped the engine. But all of that pushrod's, rocker's, & valve's movement comes from the lifter - if the lifter sticks (anywhere), that pushrod/rocker/valve would have just stayed in-place. So that can't be what happened.

It has to have been a stuck valve. Since the stud is in-position, the valve is the only thing that could have relieved enough of the spring's load from the pushrod for it to come out of its socket in the rocker.When it's NOT stuck, and the spring is in-place: too hard for you to do by hand, even with all your weight. If you use a spring compressor, and remove the keepers: the valve should drop into the cylinder under its own weight (assuming you aren't preventing it from doing so). With the spring & keepers in-place, tapping it with a medium-sized hammer (not a tack hammer, and not a BFH) should cause it to barely open & close faster than you can see. But it will look, sound, & feel distinctly different from tapping on a rocker stud, so you can compare it to that.

But if it's sticky, it will look, sound, & feel very similar to the stud; or it may delay closing long enough for you to notice that it didn't come back up at the same time as the hammer; or it may just stay down & each hammer tap will push it down slightly more, until there's enough spring compression to slam it shut.

Those tests will cost you NOTHING but a few minutes, and then you'll KNOW what happened. How you fix it is your choice, but a fuel additive is a cheap test while you're saving nickels for new heads.

Read you're post and it makes 100% sense to me...Read it twice and it made 110% sense to me... As a aircraft owner I'm familiar with "stuck" valves even though Lycoming (like mine and unlike Continental) uses hollow sodium filed valve stems to better dissipate the heat to the guides and into the heads and thus has a much less repetition for sticking valves.. I've helped fellow pilots and mechanics perform a process called "staking the valves" on Continentals before.. In my feeble mind I never connected the old 302 to that scenario.. We normally use MMO in a spray bottle to continuously spraying MMO into the valve guides while hammering on the valve tip with brass bump bar to free it up... There is also a procedure using a piece of rope and another that actually uses a valve guide reamer tool to open up the valve guides back to factory specs.. I run MMO in every other tank of fuel in my a/c as well as Avblend and Camguard additives... I think I will start using Camguard in the old bronco too. However at $22 a pint it ain't cheap.. Referencing what you mentioned about "infrequently used" has big merits in an aircraft engine and is one of the big advantages and reasons for these additives. Flying conditions like "low and slow" do not promote conditions for proper leaning on the fuel air mixture that allows for "burning off of carbon deposits in combustion chamber, valve seats and valve guides.. I've seen many aircraft engines that developed low compression on a cylinder be "fixed" using the old lacquer thinner method. Simply get the cylinder on TDC compression stroke and fill the cylinder through and up to the top spark plug hole with it and let it sit for 4-5 hours. Then pull the bottom spark plug and drain the thinner and recheck the compression.. I've seen it rise from 10-20 psi afterwards.. This is usually done in conjunction with a oil change afterwards.. Well, I guess I know what I'll be doing tomorrow... Thanks guys!!
 

DJs74

Bronco Guru
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
1,135
Thanks guys for all the data, I've learned a lot here so far.. Looks like I've got positive stop studs, and when I removed the stud nut I'm thinking it had nothing like 20 ft lbs of torque on it? I measured the push rod at 6.883" and I know it has an "other that stock" cam but not sure just how aggressive.. The build sheet says a 275 Comp cam?? I do know that the rockers are Comp cam 1.6's but this truck has been full of surprises, some pleasant and some not do pleasant.. The push rod was leaned over but not rubbing the edge of the hole cast in the head.. I rolled the push rod on a very flat surface and it took off and seemed to roll very true with no wobble or humping.. I laid a machine tool straight edge across the top of both the adjacent studs and it doesn't appear to be any longer than those, but my eyes ain't what they use to be and had at least 3 different lights shinning on it at the time? When using a longer straight edge to span more studs, I get interference from the rocker arms I guess due to their position.. I'm pretty sure they are rail rockers but will post a pic shortly so maybe you guys can verify this.. The push rods are hollow so I'm assuming they are hydraulic? I'm leaning towards just pulling the other valve cover, removing the spark plugs and going through the procedure and torque the nuts to 20 ft/lbs and maybe put some blue thread locker on the studs (what could it hurt) .. Then again, maybe I should do the "Dry erase" marker method to verify push rod lengths simply so I will know what I have here regarding cam, heads, valve seats etc..? Thanks again..

Looking at the middle photo showing the valve and spring, it looks like the valve tip is deformed or "mushroomed", might be an optical illusion on my screen I guess but if it is, that is a flag and likely related to the rocker arm becoming misaligned and coming off the valve.
In the same photo, there appears to be a wear mark in the stud just above the stud boss - that could've happened after the rocker arm jumped off the valve or possibly another indication of valvetrain geometry issues - worn valve guide, incorrect pushrod length, worn rocker ball, improper valve adjustment, ???

I think I'd start from scratch and verify everything... inspect the valve spring for a broken coil, check valve spring installed height, inspect the rocker arm ball for wear, verify pushrod length is correct, purchase a new set of rocker arm nuts at minimum and maybe a new set of rocker arm balls if the current ones show signs of wear.

It's stated that the build sheet specifies a Comp Cam 275, assuming that is Comp Cam P/N: 31-418-3, there are two different springs listed for this camshaft: 942-16 & 972-16
942-16
► installed height of 1.700"
► coil bind height of 1.125"
► OD of Ø1.437
► 339 lbs. / inch spring rate
972-16
► installed height of 1.800"
► coil bind height of 1.195"
► OD of Ø1.46
► 308 lbs. / inch spring rate

Lift with 1.6 ratio rockers = 0.477 Intake / 0.510 Exhaust

2 different suggested pushrods: one is 6.881" and the other is 6.900" as a reference only. This needs to be verified based on the actual application, cylinder heads & valvetrain geometry by performing a wear pattern test between the rocker arm roller tip and the valve tip.

With the rocker arm stud being verified as OK, I'd suspect either a collapsed lifter or as mentioned by others, the valve might've hung after it opened - both of these scenarios would cause the pushrod to become loose at the lifter and the rocker arm allowing the rocker arm to jump off the valve.

The pushrods being hollow are not related to being a hydraulic camshaft, the pushrods have holes to supply oil to the rocker arm, rocker ball, rocker arm nut for lubrication at the pivot. Hydraulic and mechanical camshafts use pushrods with thru holes.

For peace of mind and so you know for sure, I would check everything related to the valvetrain geometry and also verify the lift at the rocker arm once you are ready to rotate the motor by hand and verify things are working properly.



DJs74
 
Last edited:

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
ribbits,
The theory that Steve83 has about the valve being stuck open sounds reasonable.
Do you think it may be possible that the engine sucked in something large enough to hold the valve open?

Since you didn't build this motor, you probably don't know what the carburetor base gasket looks like. I've seen the incorrect four hole gasket used on open and split plenum intakes. The unsupported center chunk of thick gasket can be torn off and sucked into the motor.
This happened on a big block Chevy motor I had. It actually held the intake valve open causing a backfire and loud tapping. It finally cleared itself, but it ran that way long enough that it would have jumped the rail with that kind of rocker.

I think it would be worth pulling the carb for a quick look.
 

Attachments

  • imagesJOAM65IU.jpg
    imagesJOAM65IU.jpg
    6.7 KB · Views: 46

tirewater

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 28, 2011
Messages
1,046
Loc.
San Francisco Bay Area
You can get a bore scope and take a looksie inside the cylinder head. I believe they make attachments for cell phones now. They're kind of hard to get angled correctly, but it would enable you to check the valve through the spark plug hole.

My hope is that you're simply a victim of incorrect assembly and that you can put it back together and not worry.
 
OP
OP
ribbits

ribbits

Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
130
Hello Guys,
Thanks for all the data but I misspoke regarding the cam.. Seems it is actually a Comp Cam 274 kit.. I know the 6.88 push rod is the same but not sure on the springs? The one rod I measured was 6.883 so that part look OK? However, I will check it all tomorrow as I'm ready to rotate the engine.
BUT THE PLOT THICKENS ... While trying to locate some replacement rocker nuts I determined that the PO or someone installed a conversion kit to change them from positive stop studs to adjustable ones via the following Comp Cam kits...?
;D
http://www.compperformancegroupstor...e_Code=CC&Product_Code=4610-16&Category_Code=

http://www.compcams.com/catalog/COMP2012/pdf/COMP_Catalog_2012_59.pdf

That would explain why none of my rocker nuts are very tight, in fact you can rotate them with two fingers and a 3/8 drive ratchet .. Also I'm little concerned about one of the attachments recommendation "for high performance applications" replacing the rocker studs with threaded ones (which I don't think I have) in conjunction with push rod guide plates.. I'm not sure but I think either would require the heads to be removed which I'm not the least bit interested in doing.. I did a little digging around on some of the Mustang sites and found where people were using these kits with success but emphasized the need to use a half thread lock nuts?? I did have a moment today to check the valve with a bump bar and hammer and glad to report that it is not stuck.. Guess I'll find out more when I rotate the engine regarding the lifters tomorrow.. But as of right now,, I'm hoping that the nuts just backed off as per feed back from the Mustang guys??
Please note the pics of my rocker upon further inspection and you can see the really thick washer that exists.. I'm hoping I can get a height dimension on the valve when at base zero to verify nothing caught under the seat.. It has a Holly Truck Avenger carb with a 2" spacer so hoping I won't have to fool with those gaskets.. Will follow up tomorrow with more info and thanks to all for the excellent advise and support..
 

Attachments

  • COMP_Catalog_2012_59.pdf
    218.3 KB · Views: 30
  • IMG_2080.jpg
    IMG_2080.jpg
    43.7 KB · Views: 60
  • IMG_2081.jpg
    IMG_2081.jpg
    52.2 KB · Views: 59
  • IMG_2082.jpg
    IMG_2082.jpg
    45.1 KB · Views: 60
OP
OP
ribbits

ribbits

Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
130
You can get a bore scope and take a looksie inside the cylinder head. I believe they make attachments for cell phones now. They're kind of hard to get angled correctly, but it would enable you to check the valve through the spark plug hole.

My hope is that you're simply a victim of incorrect assembly and that you can put it back together and not worry.

You know what.. I have one made by Rigid with a 4" screen and recording ability..forgot about it.. Looks like trip the hanger is in order tomorrow... Thanks
 
OP
OP
ribbits

ribbits

Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
130
Those look great !! Will have to check to make sure they will fit under the valve covers? Thanks
Crap!! ..Quick check but doesn't looks like they have them for 5/16"x24 nuts??
But will look elsewhere for similar ones..
 

DJs74

Bronco Guru
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
1,135
Hello Guys,
Thanks for all the data but I misspoke regarding the cam.. Seems it is actually a Comp Cam 274 kit.. I know the 6.88 push rod is the same but not sure on the springs? The one rod I measured was 6.883 so that part look OK? However, I will check it all tomorrow as I'm ready to rotate the engine.
BUT THE PLOT THICKENS ... While trying to locate some replacement rocker nuts I determined that the PO or someone installed a conversion kit to change them from positive stop studs to adjustable ones via the following Comp Cam kits...?
;D
http://www.compperformancegroupstor...e_Code=CC&Product_Code=4610-16&Category_Code=

http://www.compcams.com/catalog/COMP2012/pdf/COMP_Catalog_2012_59.pdf

That would explain why none of my rocker nuts are very tight, in fact you can rotate them with two fingers and a 3/8 drive ratchet .. Also I'm little concerned about one of the attachments recommendation "for high performance applications" replacing the rocker studs with threaded ones (which I don't think I have) in conjunction with push rod guide plates.. I'm not sure but I think either would require the heads to be removed which I'm not the least bit interested in doing.. I did a little digging around on some of the Mustang sites and found where people were using these kits with success but emphasized the need to use a half thread lock nuts?? I did have a moment today to check the valve with a bump bar and hammer and glad to report that it is not stuck.. Guess I'll find out more when I rotate the engine regarding the lifters tomorrow.. But as of right now,, I'm hoping that the nuts just backed off as per feed back from the Mustang guys??
Please note the pics of my rocker upon further inspection and you can see the really thick washer that exists.. I'm hoping I can get a height dimension on the valve when at base zero to verify nothing caught under the seat.. It has a Holly Truck Avenger carb with a 2" spacer so hoping I won't have to fool with those gaskets.. Will follow up tomorrow with more info and thanks to all for the excellent advise and support..

The conversion to adjustable valvetrain is a good thing - now each valve has (or is supposed to have) a specific independent adjustment instead of a positive stop / torqued to X value.

Although I have never purchased or used a 5/16-24 polylocks, apparently they exist, here is a link: https://www.summitracing.com/parts/isk-pl516/overview/

The special washers are critical to use and are orientation specific, they have a stepped shoulder diameter and must be installed correctly - large diameter down first, smaller diameter against the nut. The rocker stud is stepped and has a larger diameter at the head than at the thread, the washer has the stepped hole so it clears the unthreaded shank portion of the stud but has a tight fit on the 5/16 thread.

Unless you happen to find a problem with the lifter or camshaft lobe, I think you'll be in good shape with a new set of polylock nuts. Just start from scratch by removing all the staked nuts, install all new polylock nuts along with the washers and go through the valve adjustment procedure (no torque value, achieve zero lash and then another 1/2 to 3/4 turn, then tighten set screw)


I use the EOIC method, start at the #1 cylinder, adjust both the intake and exhaust at a time, follow the firing order and turn the motor over by hand all the way through (as opposed to using the starter). I also remove all the spark plugs... just lets the motor turn over easier.

You don't need guide plates because you have the self aligning rocker arms, you are good there - no problem.



DJs74
 

DJs74

Bronco Guru
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
1,135
ribbits:
Hello Guys,
Thanks for all the data but I misspoke regarding the cam.. Seems it is actually a Comp Cam 274 kit.. I know the 6.88 push rod is the same but not sure on the springs?




Assuming the "274" is Comp Cam P/N: 31-246-3

Recommended valve springs are 986-16 & 987-16

986-16
► installed height of 1.750"
► coil bind height of 1.150"
► OD of Ø1.430
► 322 lbs. / inch spring rate
987-16
► installed height of 1.800"
► coil bind height of 1.150"
► OD of Ø1.430
► 370 lbs. / inch spring rate

Same pushrods as discussed for the "275" @ 6.881" & 6.900"


DJs74
 
OP
OP
ribbits

ribbits

Jr. Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2015
Messages
130
ribbits:
Hello Guys,
Thanks for all the data but I misspoke regarding the cam.. Seems it is actually a Comp Cam 274 kit.. I know the 6.88 push rod is the same but not sure on the springs?




Assuming the "274" is Comp Cam P/N: 31-246-3

Recommended valve springs are 986-16 & 987-16

986-16
► installed height of 1.750"
► coil bind height of 1.150"
► OD of Ø1.430
► 322 lbs. / inch spring rate
987-16
► installed height of 1.800"
► coil bind height of 1.150"
► OD of Ø1.430
► 370 lbs. / inch spring rate

Same pushrods as discussed for the "275" @ 6.881" & 6.900"


DJs74

Thank you DJs,,,, I was hoping you caught the hint!! It is preserved in my files for posterity..
 

Boss Hugg

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 8, 2010
Messages
2,213
Don't have time to read the whole thread, but what's the possibility the valves floated and one pushrod fell out of place?

My initial thought tho, was collapsed lifter.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Top