• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Roll cage welding - multiple passes necessary?

DanWheeler

Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 8, 2005
Messages
2,572
Loc.
Kirkland, WA
I put in a 6 point WH San Felipe cage last weekend and my neighbor who used to be a pipe welder was saying a single pass is not safe. Did I screw this thing up? I have a 110 mig Lincoln and I welded the front tubes on the highest setting w/ medium-high line feed.

he was saying i should have done a cold pass, slow feed then go over the whole thing again with a hot pass, high feed.

should i grind it all down and do it again?

thanks,
dan
 

Skiddy

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 8, 2003
Messages
11,587
I put in a 6 point WH San Felipe cage last weekend and my neighbor who used to be a pipe welder was saying a single pass is not safe. Did I screw this thing up? I have a 110 mig Lincoln and I welded the front tubes on the highest setting w/ medium-high line feed.

he was saying i should have done a cold pass, slow feed then go over the whole thing again with a hot pass, high feed.

should i grind it all down and do it again?

thanks,
dan

No you should be fine also depends on how big your gaps were, if you can take a pic and we can look at them. be back in am if you have more questions. time to go home;D
 

trailpsycho

Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 11, 2003
Messages
4,856
Yeah, its hard to say. Theoretically, the 110 unit should have the guts to fully penetrate the 1/8" thick tube, but unless your an expert, I would definitely have done as your neighbor said or tacked it up and found a 220 V unit to really meld it properly.

Most of my cage was done at my fabricator-friend's shop (using a HD unit)...all the structural welds...later on I added some rear floor sections for the storage box and rear seat (with a 110 V unit)...all of that I did using flux-core with mulitple passes in places that were "structural" for safety...seat belts were several passes (1/4" tabs). We later made a change to the front bar for visibility at the dash and I went back tro his shop (had to maks a couple of bends) and used his high end Miller 220 V unit and there was a clear and obvious difference in the penetration and look of the weld compared to my 110 unit. There is no substitution for deep penetration. :-X I now have welder envy.%)

Photos of the welds would help determine if there are any problems with the welds. I am guessing here...but since your neighbor said something after looking at your work...that says something right there...assuming he did look at it. You may ask him if you did clean up/out some of the weld if he would be willing to make a pass or two with his unit (assuming he has access to a 220V unit at home). That is assuming that you do want the cage to have optimal structural integrity.
 
OP
OP
DanWheeler

DanWheeler

Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 8, 2005
Messages
2,572
Loc.
Kirkland, WA
he did take a look but said there's no way to tell just by looking at it. In some places the gaps were up to 1/8" and some places there was no gap at all. It was really hard to make a fishmouth cut that fits perfectly on a 90 degree bend where the pipe diameter is smaller because of the bend.

here are some close up pics

328878324_BqHYz-M.jpg


328878327_Zpuz8-M.jpg


the 4 places I welded were the bottom plates on the front side-bars and where the side-bars connect to the main hoop at the bend.

328878491_KvQXA-M.jpg


325885739_4B3PN-M.jpg
 

broncow72

Village Idiot
Joined
Jun 5, 2005
Messages
2,174
Loc.
Spring,TX.
Can't see the discoloration due to the paint. But I'd say if there was blueing 1/2" to 3/4" from the weld, then you should have good penetration.

Anyone correct me if I'm misguided on this theory.
 

00gyrhed

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 3, 2006
Messages
2,428
Your pipe welder niehbor is over reacting a little and erring on the safe side since he has no idea how good a welder you are, or how well you set up the connections.

Pardon me if I get this wrong it has been a long time since I took the certification test. It may also have changed in 30 years.

Pipe welders make three passes. The pipe is beveled and set up with a gap equal to the rods size used. a stringer pass fills the gap, then the flux is chipped and and ground. A second pass is also treated that way then the final. Thats what it takes to reliably contain fluids under pressure, and maintian the strenth of the pipe wall for structural support.

In order to be certified they will take your welds done in this manner and x-ray them and cut strips through the weld so that they can take these strips and put it in a vice and hit it with a hammer until it bends over on it self. If the weld breaks you fail. You have to do it they way described in order for the weld strengh to pass the fold over test.

Your roll bar doesn't really need that kind of strength.

If you maintained a good puddle, had some gap and/or bevel on both sides it is probably just fine for a roll bar.

I have subjected pipe bumpers to a single pass, and even groung them smooth. Been in a nasty wreck where I was rearended by a knucle head on a cell phone going 50. I actually expected to see some broken welds and was surprised when none were broken.

It all boils down to how you feel about your penetration and your puddle in a single pass. Mostly your welds look pretty good maybe a little cold but everyone says I weld too hot. :)
 

Grizzly4x4

Jr. Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2008
Messages
68
Loc.
Where the snow is
I'd have to say that your joints look too cold. See how the weld is build up but edges don't flow into the tube? IMO it takes a really good 110v welder to get good penetration for a cage, I know my cheap 110v welder can't do it.

My recommendation would be to grind down the center part of the welds and hit them with another couple passes.

328878324bqhyzmls8.jpg


328878327zpuz8mzm2.jpg
 

NYLES

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 13, 2004
Messages
9,846
Stick it!

I mig'ed mine to do again Id stick it! Myself and Gordn at Bailie built welds look great but I weld ALOT better with a stick.
 

00gyrhed

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 3, 2006
Messages
2,428
I actually agree

Stick it!

I mig'ed mine to do again Id stick it! Myself and Gordn at Bailie built welds look great but I weld ALOT better with a stick.

Burn it in with a good hot stick. not sure I would bother to grind it.
 

RedLeg0811

Sr. Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2006
Messages
837
Loc.
Maltby, WA
The welds mostly look nice, but nice doesn't cover full penitration. There are some weld that look cold rold. I think I would have done a multiple pass. If you didn't I also would have beveled the fish mouth.

Hope that make sense I am still in a hospital drug stuper.

Martin
 

eb66to77

Bronc'Ownly
Joined
Mar 26, 2005
Messages
2,558
Loc.
NOVA
I am working with pipe fitting right now and most of the fitters say and do all stick for structural stuff like this. Our boilermaker bevels, wire wheels, welds a filler bead, wire wheels (not grinds), and then runs a little larger rod over everything. The first pass is to get the penetration and the second pass is to ensure all of it is together and allows for a bit of flex in the joint. I was before I started working there a strict MIG guy. Now I am stick welding every piece of scrap I see to practice.
 

357Bronco

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 13, 2006
Messages
1,001
Loc.
New Hampsha
Some of the joints look cold, but it could be from not keeping the torch at the right angle for good penetration. Welding around a pipe consistently is not always easy. I would look more for the blueing around the weld as more of a sign of a good weld. Any pics of before the paint?
 

bgs26

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 30, 2005
Messages
493
Loc.
Eunice, LA
I work for a major natural gas pipeline company. I am an equipment operator but I work alongside 4 welders every week. They are excellent welders. Their work is as slick as owl shit. We follow the API 1104 procedure. The pipe is beveled and a root pass is made and the slag is ground out. The next pass is the hot pass and run over with a buffing wheel. The rest of the passes are filler passes to fill the bevel and each one is buffed off with a wire wheel. The final pass is the cap and is purely for appearance. After all this the welds are x-rayed and have to pass certain specs. This procedure is for pipelines that hold hundreds and sometimes thousands of lbs. of pressure. This is probably what your neighbor is used to. If I were you (depending on how you feel about your welding skills) I would buff off the paint, possibly grind down the weld a little, and make another pass.
 

kbldawg

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 26, 2007
Messages
1,492
Loc.
Marshall, AR
You can take a cut-off wheel and grind a groove right down the center of those bad welds and then burn it in again.
 

Madgyver

Bronco Madman
Joined
Jul 30, 2001
Messages
15,030
You can take a cut-off wheel and grind a groove right down the center of those bad welds and then burn it in again.
I 2nd that....
Practice on some scrap pieces 1st.. Look like you need to go hotter... Stitch it if you need to....

yep, root pass, hot pass, fill pass and then cap it off.....
Some fitters will also use a TIG for the root pass.....

Lets hear what Skiddy has to say... I believe he is an inspector for welding.

submit your xray and coupon below....;D
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
I have seen "professionally" welded cages that look way worse then that.
 

uncle ray

Full Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2006
Messages
165
another tip to crutch a 110 welder, though also too late to do any good here, is to preheat the area with an oxy/acetylene torch. this will go a long way towards making strong welds with a 110 welder. heck, even a propane torch can do the trick. i notice a big difference in penetration between welding on a cold day vs. a 90 degree day out in the sun.
 

HoosierDaddy

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
May 29, 2006
Messages
2,776
It appears that the bead is on top of the metal in a few areas , but Broncobowsher put things into perspective very nicely a post or two above.
Otherwise , not too shabby looking , especially considering they are on pipe.
 
Top