Your pipe welder niehbor is over reacting a little and erring on the safe side since he has no idea how good a welder you are, or how well you set up the connections.
Pardon me if I get this wrong it has been a long time since I took the certification test. It may also have changed in 30 years.
Pipe welders make three passes. The pipe is beveled and set up with a gap equal to the rods size used. a stringer pass fills the gap, then the flux is chipped and and ground. A second pass is also treated that way then the final. Thats what it takes to reliably contain fluids under pressure, and maintian the strenth of the pipe wall for structural support.
In order to be certified they will take your welds done in this manner and x-ray them and cut strips through the weld so that they can take these strips and put it in a vice and hit it with a hammer until it bends over on it self. If the weld breaks you fail. You have to do it they way described in order for the weld strengh to pass the fold over test.
Your roll bar doesn't really need that kind of strength.
If you maintained a good puddle, had some gap and/or bevel on both sides it is probably just fine for a roll bar.
I have subjected pipe bumpers to a single pass, and even groung them smooth. Been in a nasty wreck where I was rearended by a knucle head on a cell phone going 50. I actually expected to see some broken welds and was surprised when none were broken.
It all boils down to how you feel about your penetration and your puddle in a single pass. Mostly your welds look pretty good maybe a little cold but everyone says I weld too hot.
