• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Holly Pro_Jection 2DI

bronco_daddy

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
343
Loc.
Paso Robles, CA
Anyone here using this system..'73 I just bought has it and I have been tweaking it along with some other things about it I want to mod..what has been you experience?
 

Oatmeal

Sr. Member
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
664
Anyone here using this system..'73 I just bought has it and I have been tweaking it along with some other things about it I want to mod..what has been you experience?
Biggest piece of crap I ever spent too much money on.........I sold it and put the carb back on. Seriously though, I had one on my old 302. Got the dual tank kit (additional pump and electric selector valve, wiring.......), closed loop kit and air/fuel ratio meter and installed an in line fuel pressure gauge to help with the tuning. My motor was fairly stock with only a little more compression and mild torque cam. Cold start was instantaneous and it ran really well once it was running (great mileage and smooth power) but, shut it off and...... good luck getting it started again! Once the motor was warmed up it was really tricky to start, do it wrong and it would flood. You had the hold the throttle just right and then, it would either flood or go into a high idle.......not ideal when you're trying to start it in gear (I have an NP 435) in a precarious, technical situation on the trail! I spent several hours (on more than one occasion) on the phone with Holley's tech dept. and they were no help at all. I finally got so fed up with it that I pulled it off and reinstalled the Edelbrock performer carb (that I hated but, carried in a plastic box....just in case) while out on the trail! I sold most of it to a guy that really wanted it for his Scout (I tried my best to talk him out of it) for $150! I saved the pumps, valve and adapter plate to use on the GM TBI conversion I plan to do (one of these days). Anyway, you asked for an opinion%) And no, it wasn't due to installer error as I'm extremely anal about how I do things. Hell, I was more knowledgable about tuning the thing than the rep I spoke with.:eek: ------------Hans
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Hey bronco_daddy. In case nobody's said it yet, welcome to CB! I see this isn't your first post, so you might already have gone through it, but what the heck.

Oatmeal has been a wealth of detailed technical knowledge, so with his direct experience, I'd say he's right on the money.
I know that's not what you wanted to hear of course, but I only know of a few people who have had their base Pro-Jections systems dialed in to the point they were happy about it. Doen't mean you can't get there, but just be ready for a lot of frustration. The concept is totally valid. It's just the implementation that seemed to work against us.

You might take a stab at the search function aboe to see what you come up with. Seems like there have been several discussions about just this subject recently.

Good luck! Hope yours is one of the ones that can be finely tuned.

Paul
 

Oatmeal

Sr. Member
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
664
Hey bronco_daddy. In case nobody's said it yet, welcome to CB! I see this isn't your first post, so you might already have gone through it, but what the heck.

Oatmeal has been a wealth of detailed technical knowledge, so with his direct experience, I'd say he's right on the money.
I know that's not what you wanted to hear of course, but I only know of a few people who have had their base Pro-Jections systems dialed in to the point they were happy about it. Doen't mean you can't get there, but just be ready for a lot of frustration. The concept is totally valid. It's just the implementation that seemed to work against us.

You might take a stab at the search function aboe to see what you come up with. Seems like there have been several discussions about just this subject recently.

Good luck! Hope yours is one of the ones that can be finely tuned.

Paul
Thanks for the support, Paul. In all fairness to Holley, after constantly screwing around with that thing, I read a small (very hard to spot) disclaimer in the installation manual, that said it was designed to be used on a totally stock, unmodified motor........my cam? still made plenty of vaccum so.......?:? ---------Hans
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Yeah, that could hamper things a bit, but the first one I had direct experience with was on a semi-stock Dodge 360. Only had headers, so it shouldn't have been too far out of spec with stock. Certainly not outside of the adjustable range of metering I wouldn't think?

The first thing we noticed was the sheer volume of fuel droplets that would spit out the top after bouncing off the throttle plates! With the air-cleaner on, you wouldn't notice. But pull it off to mess with things and you'd get a face (and engine compartment) full of gas.

Paul
 
OP
OP
bronco_daddy

bronco_daddy

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
343
Loc.
Paso Robles, CA
Ah no worries and I rather not hear what one may think I want to..a little thicker skinned than that.

Truck runs decent with the newer digital comp in it but as Paul stated, for TBI it is a very sloppy injection on the spray angles and on the droplets. I am quite familiar with FI from manufacturing for the auto industry and usually you put a timing light to it and check for droplets and/or skewed spray angles.

From my understanding they have a higher pressure rate nozzle that is approx 5 more lbs which can make a sizable difference in the spray pattern and atomization.

From what I was seeing, it was just dumping weakly and over fueling so I put in some queries to some injector dealers to see what they can do and what injector is this..it appears GM. I am going to spend time with it dealing with dwell, supply and return pressure because they are not the easiest to set up.

Holly wants $159 each and I have seen them (if it is the ones) for under $40 a pair. I am going to bench test them or even put my fuel injection cleaning machine on them and run the psi up and play with return restriction and see how the pattern and particles clean up and the motor runs.

Anyways, thanks for the welcome and no worries giving me a bad opinion..if I have to go to a carb, no big thing but rather not..also looking at a DUI Dist and open the plug gaps and see if it gets more pop..

Oatmeal... hah! Covina?? Grew up there, Charter Oak High Class of 80 and my parents are still there..my manufacturing shop is ther behind the dam in Irwindale.

Dirt Donk..SJ? I am down in Salinas with the Fire Department though I reside in Paso Robles..lookiie at all my new neighbors!
 
OP
OP
bronco_daddy

bronco_daddy

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
343
Loc.
Paso Robles, CA
If I cannot tweak the system within reason then I will opt out for a Edelbrock Performer Intake #2121 dual plane, Performer 4bbl Carb #1403 which is 600cfm good throttle response and good low end torque and very crisp..grea combo with an RV cam..solid package.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Salinas eh? We used to get a lot of search & rescue and fire vehicles in for custom bumpers at the Hanson shop.
Hopefully headin' that way next week (unless otherwise occupied in Marina) for some Chinese booofay lunch with some Bronco buddies.
Haven't been to Paso Robles to see my friends there for some time. Too long.

Yep, world's gettin' smaller every day.

Paul
 
OP
OP
bronco_daddy

bronco_daddy

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
343
Loc.
Paso Robles, CA
Salinas for Chineese? Uck...you must be hardcore. If ever you caome to PR, love to meet you for a beer but not Chineese..even worse here
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,110
Biggest piece of crap I ever spent too much money on.........I sold it and put the carb back on. Seriously though, I had one on my old 302. Got the dual tank kit (additional pump and electric selector valve, wiring.......), closed loop kit and air/fuel ratio meter and installed an in line fuel pressure gauge to help with the tuning. My motor was fairly stock with only a little more compression and mild torque cam. Cold start was instantaneous and it ran really well once it was running (great mileage and smooth power) but, shut it off and...... good luck getting it started again! Once the motor was warmed up it was really tricky to start, do it wrong and it would flood. You had the hold the throttle just right and then, it would either flood or go into a high idle.......not ideal when you're trying to start it in gear (I have an NP 435) in a precarious, technical situation on the trail! I spent several hours (on more than one occasion) on the phone with Holley's tech dept. and they were no help at all. I finally got so fed up with it that I pulled it off and reinstalled the Edelbrock performer carb (that I hated but, carried in a plastic box....just in case) while out on the trail! I sold most of it to a guy that really wanted it for his Scout (I tried my best to talk him out of it) for $150! I saved the pumps, valve and adapter plate to use on the GM TBI conversion I plan to do (one of these days). Anyway, you asked for an opinion%) And no, it wasn't due to installer error as I'm extremely anal about how I do things. Hell, I was more knowledgable about tuning the thing than the rep I spoke with.:eek: ------------Hans

Well your comments state that you were NOT working with a 2DI system. but more then likely the old analog projection. Once again Holley projection is being lumped into a single program when it is not. There are several diffferent versions of the Projection system
The lowest and crappiest (and what a lot of people bought when it first came out and now gets a ton of bad feedback) is the old analog system. 5 knobs on the box, no O2 sensor (but kit availible)
Then there was the "D" or digital. Can't remember if it had O2 or not. Tuned about the same way but with plug in knobs.
Then through the late 90's the high end, the "DI" or Digital Interactive. This one takes a laptop to get dialed in. Rev limiter, O2 switching voltage, a bunch of stuff is programable. Still a pain to do, but can be done far better then the old analog systems. O2 sensor was standard for this.
I have not played with the latest and greatest Commander 950 system the Holley makes.

So just to be fair, when you have questions about Holley fuel injection and are looking at feedback, make sure the feedback you get actually matches the model you are playing with.

--end rant on generalizing Holley ProJection---

So you are working on an existing already installed system. Did you get the software disks with the truck? without those you are not doing anything. You really should have the manual as well. The copies I had just went with the last Bronco I sold so I don't have mine anymore either.

If it is an older DI system with an older ROM, there are some firmware issues that anything newer then Windows 95 (pre SE version) won't run. I updated my old laptop and was locked out of the fuel injection for several years. Found an old laptop that had been hiding in a closet for years that had an old enough operating system that I could get into the fuel injection again. After talking with Holley about it they have an updated ROM that could have fixed mine so I could use a newer laptop. I never bothered to update. But if you have the disks, and the cable and can't get the two to talk, that may be your issue.

With it set up right it ran good. I was running a 351W that was no slouch. Had small cam and Trickflow heads on it. IT was EFI so it always started and ran the same regardless of angle. It controlled idle so it idled the same. Lug it, and it would add a little idle to keep it going. did pretty much anything any other factory EFI could do except that I could change the settings. Want 50 more RPM of idle, few keystrokes and it is done. Lean on the top end, add more fuel just to the top end.

I ran the DI system for 10 years. And I got it used. I would not have left it there that long if it was that bad.
I also knew people who had the old analog system, mounted to the bottom of the dash so they could turn the knobs as they drove down the road to get them to run right. I don't think any of them still have that system anymore.
 

Oatmeal

Sr. Member
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
664
Well your comments state that you were NOT working with a 2DI system. but more then likely the old analog projection. Once again Holley projection is being lumped into a single program when it is not. There are several diffferent versions of the Projection system
The lowest and crappiest (and what a lot of people bought when it first came out and now gets a ton of bad feedback) is the old analog system. 5 knobs on the box, no O2 sensor (but kit availible)
Then there was the "D" or digital. Can't remember if it had O2 or not. Tuned about the same way but with plug in knobs.
Then through the late 90's the high end, the "DI" or Digital Interactive. This one takes a laptop to get dialed in. Rev limiter, O2 switching voltage, a bunch of stuff is programable. Still a pain to do, but can be done far better then the old analog systems. O2 sensor was standard for this.
I have not played with the latest and greatest Commander 950 system the Holley makes.

So just to be fair, when you have questions about Holley fuel injection and are looking at feedback, make sure the feedback you get actually matches the model you are playing with.

--end rant on generalizing Holley ProJection---

So you are working on an existing already installed system. Did you get the software disks with the truck? without those you are not doing anything. You really should have the manual as well. The copies I had just went with the last Bronco I sold so I don't have mine anymore either.

If it is an older DI system with an older ROM, there are some firmware issues that anything newer then Windows 95 (pre SE version) won't run. I updated my old laptop and was locked out of the fuel injection for several years. Found an old laptop that had been hiding in a closet for years that had an old enough operating system that I could get into the fuel injection again. After talking with Holley about it they have an updated ROM that could have fixed mine so I could use a newer laptop. I never bothered to update. But if you have the disks, and the cable and can't get the two to talk, that may be your issue.

With it set up right it ran good. I was running a 351W that was no slouch. Had small cam and Trickflow heads on it. IT was EFI so it always started and ran the same regardless of angle. It controlled idle so it idled the same. Lug it, and it would add a little idle to keep it going. did pretty much anything any other factory EFI could do except that I could change the settings. Want 50 more RPM of idle, few keystrokes and it is done. Lean on the top end, add more fuel just to the top end.

I ran the DI system for 10 years. And I got it used. I would not have left it there that long if it was that bad.
I also knew people who had the old analog system, mounted to the bottom of the dash so they could turn the knobs as they drove down the road to get them to run right. I don't think any of them still have that system anymore.
I think I would know what I bought, installed, removed and ultimately sold%) It was this unit here: http://www.pirate4x4.com/tech/projection/ 2DI, where 2=2barrel, D=digital, I=injection. No laptop programing, no idle air control motor. Bought the optional closed loop kit (oxygen sensor) to go with it and the air/fuel ratio meter (fed info from the oxygen sensor) to help with the tuning. Like I stated in my earlier post, I really liked the way it ran, but the hot start issue was totally unacceptable......isn't that one of the reasons one would want EFI? If you read the write up in the Pirate 4X4 link, it says "the engine is very easy to start up when its cold or has been parked for a long time"........what about hot start? So, please don't tell me what I DIDN'T have. ----------Hans
 

Oatmeal

Sr. Member
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
664
Another thing I'd like to add (kinda funny, actually). I got the idea of running the Pro-Jection from a feature article I read in Off Road magazine about 17 yrs ago. In this article, there was a guy that had a SBC powered Land Cruiser and he, was running this exact same setup but, they didn't go into detail about it. I later find out that he has an automotive repair shop in Pasadena (where I lived for most of my life) so, I sought him out to ask him how he got his to run satisfactorily and his reply was "I took it off and put it back in the box" seems he had the same issues I was experiencing.......he installed a Q-Jet in it's place and was much happier. I too, replaced my Performer carb (which really wasn't happy in offroad, off camber situations) with a Q-Jet.....it was the next best thing (and worlds better than the Pro-Jection) to EFI. That was on my 302 but, my 351W will be getting the GM stuff........eventually.---------Hans
 
OP
OP
bronco_daddy

bronco_daddy

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
343
Loc.
Paso Robles, CA
the truck came with the system, all the books, reciepts from the day it was (the truck) plus every recipet for every thing was was ever put in or on it and all in binders so I have everything. It is the Pro-Jection 2D with upgraded Comp which recipets show and give numbers for. The manual(s) show nothing wither regard to computer linking...the system is very simple overall, almost too simple. It has the comp w/5 adjustment pots and an O2 sensor mounted passenger side exhaust. The systems was analog and yes there was a lot of problems in which a computer change was made by Holly to Digital, new comp was $500...so we have analog system initially upgraded to digital.

Reading over at Pirate 4X4 alot of people had big problems but resolved them with a lot of fine tuning (analog). I know a little about FI having owned a manufacturing business that made the equipment for BG, WYNNS, etc for your fuel injection cleaning systems..plus owned a reman company for Detroit Diesel and Cummins recon for their FI systems, so I know what a nozzle pattern should look like and this systems has too many drips and a weak spray pattern and that is the source of the issues in which I am trying to learn the electrical side of this..I am a mechanical guy, I know injectors themselves and I am trying to learn all the other particulars that create a good running system and the TPS appears to be a real issue and getting it dialed right is what makes it really perfom. If you go and look at a standard Suburban TBI and its spray pattern and cleanliness of the atomization and you look at what this particular system is doing, it would not sit too well with you and I know it can do better.

So, sorry I touched a nerve with you and uncovered some old wound and my question is/was to talk with those whom have these systems because alot of it, regardless of how many variations there are, they are transferrable to a point. My deal is at cold, it takes a good 10 mins to warm up and run right..once the system is hot, it runs decent but is over fueling and that I am contribuing to the spray pattern plus dropslets plus as I will find out is some measurement issues and maybe some pressure issues also..system was installed in Tennessee by a performance shop. Its not bad, it just is not 100%and I would put it at maybe 75% in it ability right now. Maybe I will play with the timing also. It always starts also..never an issue with that and Oatmeal is right about the 2DI...at least his and mine has no compute programming.

I am at the fire station and tomorrow when I am home I will go over the books again and report back...I may have missed something.
 

Oatmeal

Sr. Member
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
664
So, sorry I touched a nerve with you and uncovered some old wound
Naw no problem, the wound has healed and only a small scar as a reminder remains;D You seem to really know what you're doing. Mine was the opposite, it ran pretty good when cold but, was dumping too much fuel during a hot start. I dunno maybe it just didn't like the cam I had but, the number of people I spoke with that had issues........ well, we could have started a support group:cry: I hope the guy I sold it to has had better luck than I did. Let us know what you come up with and maybe you should do a write up on your results. Oh, and by the way, welcome to the group:) The guys (and gals.......trying to be PC) here are much nicer than the Pirate 4X4 bunch:eek:-------Hans
 

73azbronco

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 11, 2007
Messages
8,781
I'm wondering, not knowing diddly about the projection stuff, that if your having hot start problems, I would look to a temp sensor being bad, is there a temp sensor included in that thing?

Lastly, as always, are you sure you don't have a intake vacuum leak? Do you have any idea what you fuel ratio is while it is running?
 

av bronco

Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 3, 2008
Messages
1,742
Loc.
Palmdale CA
Everytinng Ive bought in the last three years from holley has been junk. wasnt like that before. holley had loyal bunch of us but the junk they have produced lately has scared me for life.
 
OP
OP
bronco_daddy

bronco_daddy

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
343
Loc.
Paso Robles, CA
From what I have been reading in a HotRod Forum and several other forums is that the wrong distributor can be the death to it for lack of a better analogy "interference." The Mallory system I have is very compatible.

I do not have any info to give first hand with regard to rations, pressures, etc. What I do know is TPS voltage range to work in now, return line needs to be large with zero pressure..fuel psi cannot have any drop below 15lbs or basically any fluctuation, run the pump wire through a relay direct to battery to alleviate voltage drop which appear to be one of the biggest issues..these are common threads in the system many have utilized to make the system run well...people either love or hate them..there is no middle ground.

So, plans are this: psi gauge under pressure and return, air/fuel mixture gauge, check wiring and if not already put relay in line and go to battery, check return line for bends/kinks/restrictions and size, pull all filters and replace.

Apparently people have more problems at high end with leaning out which is why the wire mod is needed..pump is dropping voltage..also everyone is mixed on the closed vs open..

Well, I wanted a project and this is going to be a good one..already contacted my friends who own Extreme Motorsports Fab whom are big into FI and Bonneville plus big HP street machines and let them work with me on this..now I am firmly embedded in making this work but a shiney new manifold, carb and bigger cam is sooooooo enticing......gotta remember this is my sons Bronco...GRRRRRRR
 
OP
OP
bronco_daddy

bronco_daddy

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
343
Loc.
Paso Robles, CA
73 Azbronco...I have no starting problems at any temp..what I have is a shaky idle when cold, loads up and the adjustable pots are not giving much leeway to adjust it out and every time yo adjust idle, etc you need to adjust the TPS again. It may be restriction in the return line, it may be some gumming in the nozzles which my FI Cleaning system will cure that with some good cleaner and high pressure run through them...also the TPS sensor and I as you where stating I may have a few sensors elsewhere going bonk....I do need to check all vac lines also.

Basically, have a vehicle which I have no history with as all of you have encountered and I am trying to make this present to my son something that is top shelf...the truck itself is cherry, beautiful to say the least but it has its issues..lots of small ones...l(lol, who am I preaching to!!?). I am just going through this whole truck section at a time and replacing all electrics, etc so I then know on my own terms where everything stands in quality and replacement time...I just HATE HATE HATE electrical.. HATE
image_12180f%20(WinCE).jpg
 
OP
OP
bronco_daddy

bronco_daddy

Full Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2010
Messages
343
Loc.
Paso Robles, CA
Talked with a gentleman today whom is highly regarded in the analog version and he is willing to help but is referring me over to another gentleman that is an engineer and has spent countless time working on the 2DI and all its issues and mods that can be done..I will then transcribe this and hopefully some pictures to make a thread on this system once and for all..they swear by the system 100%.
 

Oatmeal

Sr. Member
Joined
May 17, 2009
Messages
664
I'm wondering, not knowing diddly about the projection stuff, that if your having hot start problems, I would look to a temp sensor being bad, is there a temp sensor included in that thing?

Lastly, as always, are you sure you don't have a intake vacuum leak? Do you have any idea what you fuel ratio is while it is running?
Yeah, I replaced the temp sensor, adjusted the fuel pressure regulator (there's an adjustment screw at the throttle body return port) set the TPS voltage per Holley's instructions, the mixture was also set to the proper stoic ratio via the control pots on the under dash mounted computer.......that was tricky as the meter is hooked to the oxygen sensor but, the mixture needs to be set with the oxygen sensor out of the loop (open loop as in not feeding data back to the computer) so, I had to rig a toggle switch that would interupt feedback to the computer but, would still supply power to the meter, no vacuum leaks etc, I bought it through Summit and they even sent me a replacement computer, thinking that, that might have been the problem (Summit, by the way, is great to deal with!)......I mean, I loved the way it ran but, the hot start issue was extremely aggravating. I once got over 17mpg on a trip home from the Rubicon! I bet if Holley would have designed it with some sort of idle air control (like a stock GM TBI system) it would have been alot better.--------Hans
 
Top