• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Aired-down: how far per one tire revolution?

Steve83

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 16, 2003
Messages
9,360
Loc.
Memphis, TN, USA, Earth, Milky Way
...the tire never slips on the ground. This isn't real ALL of the time...
It isn't true ANY of the time - not even at full pressure. You're over-simplifying the issue, which is why real-world experiences (like the taxi example) don't agree with your idealized theory.
Tires do this when they're going straight. They slip/scrub slightly due to compression. The distance of an arc is longer than the distance of a line and the tire is traveling along a line at the contact patch. ... It does it by compressing the tread (and thus shortening the overall circumference) along the contact patch.
This is CORRECT. Normal road/highway tires (including ATs & most mud tires) have woven steel belts in the tread, which absolutely prevent them from expanding due to air pressure. That's why they can tolerate 40-100psi, and wide temperature ranges.

But those belts do NOT prevent them from compressing (something a cast-Iron track can't do), which makes them SHORTER - by a very small amount for a very brief time, but all those compressions add up because a 33" tire makes about 800 revs per mile. So if it only compressed 1/16" per rev (which is MUCH less than reality), that would be 4 feet lost per mile.

Here's another way to check it yourself (anyone):
Measure your newest tire's actual circumference off the ground using the thinnest most-flexible tape measure you can get (like a fabric tape, or the paper kind that Ikea gives out free - it has to be ~10' long). Then do the math of how many revs that would make per mile. Then look up the manufacturer's published RevsPerMile for that exact model & size tire - I bet it's MORE than what you calculated. That's because the published number is an average from real-world testing of the tire, when it's compressed under a vehicle's weight, which means it has to make more revs to go a mile.
How can it be any less?
Because it's rubber molded over flexible wire belts, which is specifically engineered to change shape. And if the shape isn't a circle, then the distance around it CAN'T be d*pi, can it?
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
Rubber is elastic. More pressure, it stretches. Cords help minimize it. You can feel a hose grow in diameter as it is pressurized. Air hose, garden hose. The more rigid the hose, the less it happens.

The error in logic is to think the rubber is a fixed size that never changes..
 

rcmbronc

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 15, 2003
Messages
2,778
Loc.
Tomah WI
Tires stretch and tires shrink. Oval racers measure tire size (circumference) all the time. The same tire on the left side at low pressure will be slightly smaller than the same tire on the right side at higher pressure. I assume street radial tires do not have the same ability as a non radial race tire. With 10 extra PSI we were able to get 1/2"-3/4" more tire circumference. Thats what we use to increase or decrease stagger. I assume dirt tires would be even more as they are more flexible. Dragster tires do this by making the tire narrower as they go faster.
 

Yeller

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
7,692
Loc.
Rogers County Oklahoma
Ever felt hydraulic hose under pressure? Tires are built more like a hydraulic hose pressure makes them true to shape but diameter and length change at a minuscule level.

That may be where some of this gets lost. We’re not saying there is absolute zero change, just not a big linear change. As @Broncobowsher sated 6psi is good for 3 revolutions per mile, any body want to the the math for percentage of difference for a 235/75-15 as he stated for a “normal” size tire? 710 revolutions per mile is the average for that size. So change, yes, measurable, yes with the correct equipment, perceptible in the real world, absolutely not.
 

Yeller

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
7,692
Loc.
Rogers County Oklahoma
Everyone keeps brining up tires designed for racing, not the same design, they are designed with different factors in mind.

Need spend some time watching a chassis dyno run…..
 
OP
OP
ntsqd

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
I've been holding to no change in circumference with pressure to keep from muddying the situation and not because I think that's the reality. But like Yeller said, while the change is measurable it is not large. I would expect that circumference change is a percentage, a very small percentage of the original, as molded circumference. Likely, as a guess, in the less than 2% zone.
That tank track analogy still holds, but it isn't exact and I cautioned in that previous thread about taking this analogy too far. A likely better analogy would be the rubber tracked tractor tracks, but I suspect those are built like a V or poly-V belt and have even less stretch than a tire does.
 
Last edited:

EPB72

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jul 13, 2019
Messages
1,216
Loc.
Pleasant Hill, CA
Yep a small change . but variable with sidewall aspect ratio , old hardened tires fresh new rubber..

but I posted this a couple years ago and recent onthe other thread, but now I have the actual tire size since the vehicle was in last week,,

Michelin 275 40r 18 both where brand new .. door jam recommended tire pressure 48 psi at that time had my lab scope testing for a wheel speed issue , once corrected,, and there was thread related I decided to run a test at that time , so scoped both rear wheel speed sensors and had a 1/2 millisecond differenceper revolution at 48 psi .. reduced pressure in one tire 10 psi, and now if recall correctly was either a 16 or 18 millisecond differnce ,,so small in this case but this would trigger a TPMS light this vehicle has an indirect TPMS system ,,
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,612
Loc.
Fremont, CA
I've been holding to no change in circumference with pressure to keep from muddying the situation and not because I think that's the reality. But like Yeller said, while the change is measurable it is not large. I would expect that circumference change is a percentage, a very small percentage of the original, as molded circumference. Likely, as a guess, in the less than 2% zone.
That tank track analogy stills, but it isn't exact and I cautioned in that previous thread about taking this analogy too far. A likely better analogy would be the rubber tracked tractor tracks, but I suspect those are built like a V or poly-V belt and have even less stretch than a tire does.
Stay the course. The discussion is bound to go sideways because people are human and can't handle a paradigm shift of this magnitude.

The conversation ALWAYS goes like this:
Zealot: "Tire pressure has a significant, measurable, and proportional impact on speedometer reading." (>50% effect)

(Assuming normal conditions, Correlation >0.9, Pressure (15<P<40), Standard construction radial tire, at static height, and nominal rolling under normal acceleration, at standard Ambient conditions, nominal environmental conditions, on road surfaces, on a vehicle on planet Earth.

Infidel: "Fact A, B, and C."

Logical Conclusion: Tire pressure has a minor, irrelevant, and casually correlated impact on speedometer reading. (<5% effect)

Zealot: "But 1, But 2 and But 3" I will totally violate the assumptions of reason, logic and introduce arbitrary and anecdotal boundary conditions. I will violate the original assertion, and make arbitrary new claims. Then Pronounce...

Zealot: "See, I'm right. Kill the Infidel..."

This has been going on for thousands of years. Just wait until I try to explain why the earth doesn't fall into the moon...
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,612
Loc.
Fremont, CA
Yep a small change . but variable with sidewall aspect ratio , old hardened tires fresh new rubber..

but I posted this a couple years ago and recent onthe other thread, but now I have the actual tire size since the vehicle was in last week,,

Michelin 275 40r 18 both where brand new .. door jam recommended tire pressure 48 psi at that time had my lab scope testing for a wheel speed issue , once corrected,, and there was thread related I decided to run a test at that time , so scoped both rear wheel speed sensors and had a 1/2 millisecond differenceper revolution at 48 psi .. reduced pressure in one tire 10 psi, and now if recall correctly was either a 16 or 18 millisecond differnce ,,so small in this case but this would trigger a TPMS light this vehicle has an indirect TPMS system ,

Usually not a good idea to introduce an additional Time Domain variable into a velocity discussion...but I'm perfectly OK with it.

It would be of some benefit to do the math and describe the effect of a nominal 1 mS difference in tone ring period. Because of course a tone ring at 1000 ppr will have different absolute Time domain solution that an tone ring at 36 ppr.

As a total side note, the 2013 Tesla Model S With 255/45/R19 inch tires, and standard suspension and (MCU-1) tire pressure algorithm is looking for ~1 psi resolution in the tire pressure result. The nominal recommended tire pressure is 42 psi. But the low pressure tire warning comes on at 41 psi. I have no idea why.
 

bmc69

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
12,015
Stay the course. The discussion is bound to go sideways because people are human and can't handle a paradigm shift of this magnitude.

The conversation ALWAYS goes like this:
Zealot: "Tire pressure has a significant, measurable, and proportional impact on speedometer reading." (>50% effect)

(Assuming normal conditions, Correlation >0.9, Pressure (15<P<40), Standard construction radial tire, at static height, and nominal rolling under normal acceleration, at standard Ambient conditions, nominal environmental conditions, on road surfaces, on a vehicle on planet Earth.

Infidel: "Fact A, B, and C."

Logical Conclusion: Tire pressure has a minor, irrelevant, and casually correlated impact on speedometer reading. (<5% effect)

Zealot: "But 1, But 2 and But 3" I will totally violate the assumptions of reason, logic and introduce arbitrary and anecdotal boundary conditions. I will violate the original assertion, and make arbitrary new claims. Then Pronounce...

Zealot: "See, I'm right. Kill the Infidel..."

This has been going on for thousands of years. Just wait until I try to explain why the earth doesn't fall into the moon...
Zealots gotta stick together. I'm a Druid myself, but we let Zealots share the campfire and some mead on occasion.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
I forgot about those early TPMS systems. Watched the tone rings from the ABS and would call a low tire with the speed picked up slightly. It was cheap, but flawed. If all tires were low, it would not see anything. A more worn tire would trigger the system. Only used a few years when first required and gone in favor of direct pressure monitoring. Even though more expensive, they worked way better.
 
OP
OP
ntsqd

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
[HIJACK] I've wondered about why we have TPMS these days. I entered the modern world recently and bought my first vehicle so equipped. Am very tempted to put all of the sensors in a short piece of capped ABS with a tire valve in one end, pressurize the whole bloody thing, and zip-tie it under the truck somewhere to be done with that warning light.
[/HIJACK]
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,612
Loc.
Fremont, CA
[HIJACK] I've wondered about why we have TPMS these days. I entered the modern world recently and bought my first vehicle so equipped. Am very tempted to put all of the sensors in a short piece of capped ABS with a tire valve in one end, pressurize the whole bloody thing, and zip-tie it under the truck somewhere to be done with that warning light.
[/HIJACK]
Interesting... For people with modern Broncos, if you air down your tires, does the TPMS nanny throw a code?
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,111
Most of the time the bomb under the seat trick won't work. The sensors sleep when not moving and when driving the rotation will wake them up. Not always, but that is how most of them work to get the 10 year battery life. The bomb under the seat generally won't shake them enough to wake them up.

The low pressure nanny goes out when air is added. I've had some that if you add air while the car is running the lights will flash to acknowledge it sees you adding air and will chirp the horn when full. You can top off the tires without a tire pressure gauge.

I have found them very useful, and probably saved a few lives. Many years ago I was towing a travel trailer. Wasn't the greatest, little squirrly. The tire pressure light came on. Felt the same, pulled into a rest stop to check anyway. Had a screw in the right rear tire and it was half flat. Without that TPMS I would never have known. It couldn't be 'felt' as the trailer felt about the same as the tire going down. Give it a little longer and the tire would have come apart and probably sent that truck and trailer into the ditch. The the very least the tire would have come apart and done lots of damage. But the tire was caught in time, fixed, and saved more money on just that single tire than what a set of new sensors costs me. And for some reason people want to rip these out and throw them away? They are too good for that.
 

Yeller

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 27, 2012
Messages
7,692
Loc.
Rogers County Oklahoma
Interesting... For people with modern Broncos, if you air down your tires, does the TPMS nanny throw a code?
Have not driven a 6G with the tires aired down but everything from Heep and Toyota does. Out wheeling out old FJ Cruiser the dash looked like a broken Christmas tree with all the lights turned on.

I do think many of the systems have too narrow of a range, on in the morning off, 3 miles later is inferiorating. My current Ram 3500 so far has my preferred method, anything over 50psi and no light, light stays off and if it does come on there really is an issue. I’d still be frustrated if I wheeled it…..
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
ntsqd

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
If they "wake up" when rolling why don't they have little linear generators in them instead of batteries? Charge up a Cap instead. I guess I'll have to dangle the ABS part from a single zip-tie. :)

Truck that I bought is a 2015 (that's a decade, sometimes two, closer to the actual date when owned than anything in my past). With the TPMS light on long enough it started responding less spry to throttle inputs. Oddly enough today going to lunch the light was off. Throttle response has returned. WTF?
My wife's car does the same thing, TPMS comes and goes. Make them actually consistently reliable and maybe people won't hate them so much.
 

bmc69

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
12,015
I do think many of the systems have too narrow of a range, on in the morning off, 3 miles later is inferiorating.
Simple fix..they just needa hit one of them servis stayshons that sells pure nitrogen for filling tires.


:cool:
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,612
Loc.
Fremont, CA
Simple fix..they just needa hit one of them servis stayshons that sells pure nitrogen for filling tires.


:cool:
Are you implying that Nitrogen doesn't follow Boyle's Law?

That pesky PV-nRT is going to get you EVERY time. If the temperature of the air drops in your tire, the pressure drops. Doesn't matter which kind of air is in it. I do realize that the Ideal Gas Law cannot be proven, and therefore must be taken from Postulate...but such is the nature of Laws.
 

jamesroney

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Sep 11, 2007
Messages
2,612
Loc.
Fremont, CA
If they "wake up" when rolling why don't they have little linear generators in them instead of batteries? Charge up a Cap instead. I guess I'll have to dangle the ABS part from a single zip-tie. :)

Truck that I bought is a 2015 (that's a decade, sometimes two, closer to the actual date when owned than anything in my past). With the TPMS light on long enough it started responding less spry to throttle inputs. Oddly enough today going to lunch the light was off. Throttle response has returned. WTF?
My wife's car does the same thing, TPMS comes and goes. Make them actually consistently reliable and maybe people won't hate them so much.
So you are saying that it was possible to invent the self-winding wrist watch, and the self-charging electric pedometer...but somehow we couldn't invent the self charging tire pressure monitor?

Seems like there's some valuable IP in that notion...
 
Top