Okay, I am not an agent, but I am in the Catastrophe Claims Business. I am not an auto adjuster and have never claimed to be, but I know a lot about it........next, what I am saying is not the gospel!!
First, I have insured all of my EB's with Hagerty for past 5 or so years until recently when I moved all my insurance to American National (Anpac). They were able to move them to a classic policy, Replacement cost, stated value policies for approximately $90.00 per YEAR. That was a far cry from the $400 a year I was paying at Hagerty.
Secondly, Hagerty WILL insure modified EB's or any or other vehicle that is custom or modified. You just need to be sure that you complete the paperwork correctly and do not try to pull the wool over the eyes. More than likely, the reason the rejected the bronco previously in this thread is because they disagreed with the value so they said no.
Lastly, what I am about to say about insurance is pretty profound I know..........here it is....ya ready! READ your policies......that's it, plain and simple. I guarantee there are people out there who think their covered or fully-covered that are not.
Now, let's say a had a 71 Bronco insured with Hagerty (FYI - hagerty never asked me for a mileage verification and there would be know way for them to prove how much I drove it...therefore, I drove it alot) with a stated value of $30,000.00 and a $500.00. FULL coverage right? Not quite
If I have a fender bender, causing the need for a new fender, 4 hours of body work and new paint on 2 panels......I am covered less my deductible.
Scenario 2 and what I think the situation most of you are concerned with: Let's say on your way home from a little saturday gathering at Hooters and you flip your EB on the freeway causing unrepairable damage or a constructive, total loss. Here's the catch.....just because you have a policy with a face value of $30,000.00 doesn't mean they will write you a check for $30k. They will owe the cost to replace the repair or replace the vehicle with a like, kind and quality vehicle. If that like kind vehicle can be purchased for $20K they will write you a check for $19.5 (minus ded.).
People (consumers, agents and even adjusters) use the term "Replacement Cost" out of context or incorrectly a lot in my business. Once again it doesn't necessarily mean policy value. Example - You buy a new Toshiba, 36" TV 4 years ago and pay $3200.00 for it. It's insured for 4 years and during a storm a lightning bolt strikes your house frying that TV. You report the claim, adjuster comes out and pays you $988.99 for the TV........you start jumping around having fits and throwing things at the adjuster reminding them that you have replacement cost. They remind you that the replacement cost "today" is $988.99. The policy will state in big bold letters that in the event of a claim, the claimant cannot gain or profit from a loss. Nothing more, nothing less.
What I would do if I were you if you were or are concerned about your insurance. Talk to your agent about again to confirm that you do have a replacement cost policy, etc. Take lots of photos of your rig (inside and out) and store them in a safe place along with any spec sheets that you have on it. Also, if you know an appraiser or can see a certified body shop (don't really know what that means) find you an appraisal form and have them complete it and sign it for you. Shop around......there are some great classic policies on the market today and they are a lot more economical than most of the carriers previously stated.
Simply do not over value your truck - this will get you into the biggest fights.
In the event of a loss it is "your" and the "insurance companies" duty to PROVE the loss. If your adjuster simply states that "it's" not worth that and "we're" not going to pay that......stand-up on the balls of your feet and fight like hell.
Here is how I settle a claim on a truck I had once (actually an employees truck but it still belonged to me). This scenario would apply to any insurance policy or vehicle. Vehicle: 2001, F-250, Platinum, 4x4, Crew Cab, 51,000 miles. Paid $42,000 brand new. Totalled in a head-on collision in late 2002. Insurance: Replacement cost.
The adjuster (who I never saw in person) calls up on the phone and asks me a few questions and wants to know what the pay-off amount is......I reply calmly that the pay-off was $21,000 but that was irrelevunt at this time. The adjuster fires off a few canned statements and says they'll get back to me after they inspect the vehicle and have a chance to write and estimate. Adj. calls back 3 days later and states they are ready to settle the loss....okay good. She offers me $23,500.00 (notice how close this is to the pay-off) minus deductible. I laugh and ask her how she arrived at this figure and she stated that she had ran 3 comp's and this was the average. I laughed again, requested that she fax those comp's to me for review and that I would contact her in a few hours. I received the comps a few minutes later and sure enough..her comps were not comps at all. One of them was a 2 wheel drive x-cab XLT, one was a 4x4 xlt crew and one was a lariat x-cab.
I jumped on the computer went to truck trader.com ran a search for 2001 F250 4x4 lariat and platinums and come up with over 20 comps within a 1000 mile radius. I threw out the high and the low, averaged the rest faxed it to her called her on the phone to explain what I had done and politely explained to her that I would accept $35,500.00 for my loss. She agreed, apologized and in two days I had my check. You see - I proved my loss.
I hope this helps and I hope I did not just totally confuse everyone.
Dale