• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Manual transmission consideration

661buster1963

Full Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2009
Messages
309
Have come to the conclusion my early bronco has too many man hours and blood sweat and beers in it to take much off-roading. I have looked at transmission options and really only considering manual transmissions (if nothing else 90% can’t drive it). Since off-roading is off the table, makes dead first gear off the table too (I fully understand why it’s desirable if you off-road, but really not if I don’t). The ax-15 and NV 3550 look nice but at some point may just have too wide a gear ratio (and cost) option based on my loose goal of:
1) getting 800 rpm min at 5 mph in lowest usable gear, and
2) getting 3000 rpm max at 60-65 mph at highest useable gear
I see the T19’s has a 4.02, 2.41, 1.41, 1.0 option that would seem to meet 1 and 2 with 35” tires and 4.11 gears or even 4.56 gears. I also see a not often talked about NP435 option with 4.56, 2.28, 1.31, and 1.00 gears. A wide gap between 1 and 2 but not as wide as some.

Anyone run the T19 with 4.02 first gear and have feedback on how it works out? Seems just wide enough a range between 1st and 4th to meet my goals and I see one local for 225$

The stock 3 speed has roughly a low gear minus high gear value of 1.99, hard to get the two goals above.
The NP435 I have on the bench with granny low as a low useable of 3.34 and high of 1, so the low minus high is 2.34: better but still tough to get the goals noted. Really need low useable gear minus high gear to be about 4 or more. The two Jeep trannies low usable minus high are 3.04 or more, possibly too high to use both 5th and first??
Any critical flaw in this thought process?
 

Nothing Special

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 25, 2016
Messages
848
Rather than subtracting you'll get a better comparison if you divide. So a 2.99:1 1st and 1:1 high is 2.99, while the same first with a 0.7:1 overdrive would be 4.27. Otherwise...

I had a close ratio T-18 in a Jeep CJ5. First gear was a non-syncro 4.02:1. With 33" tires an 4.27 gears it was still too low to start in very well. And the pretty big gap to 2.41:1 2nd gear , with a heavy shift of a non-syncro, made it a lot less fun to drive.

My thoughts are rambling as I write this, but... More important than the speeds in 1st and high, I'd look at how smooth does it shift and what are the gaps between the gears. I've driven the T-18 and an NP435. I don't mind driving transmissions like that in a truck, but in a toy that's supposed to be fun to drive? Not what I'd want. I do like the NV3550 in my Bronco now, although for "fun to drive" I'd probably prefer 4:56 or even lower axle gears with my 33" tires (for the driving I do I do really like the 4:10s)
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
kinda lost on your low usable minus high thought process. But I understand not wanting a dead gear. A t19 would probably be your best bet. The 435 with a 4.56 first gear is fairly rare and came in gm and dodges so may be hard to find even then its a chance that the gears will even swap over to a ford case. I kinda like the np435 even if the granny is only really usable onroad actually I've used granny on road a few times(steep hill starts or mall crawl) its has its benefits being there even if unused most of the time. Kinda like your transfer case its there but your not gonna use it? Overall I've never really noticed a lag or wanted a in between gears with the 435 but thats me and that 3.44 first is definetly better than the stock 3 speed first.

For the most part Id go with about anything you've mentioned even if it has a extra or dead gear. As pretty much there all better than the stock 3sp. While you may not want to take the bronco off road at this point you may some day and that gear may be useable again. Or even on the flip side something with a OD would also be a good idea as you can run axle gearing to get the lower speeds you want while maintaining your hiway RPM. Either way having extra is better than having none.
Id say it really boils down to what you want to spend on your setup. You have np on the bench Id say use it. as anything else is gonna cost more unless you get real lucky.
 
Last edited:

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
Another option, the Mazda 5-speed from the F150. A car like 5-speed.

3000 RPM at 60 is a bit excessive. With an overdrive transmission knocking that RPM down to 2200-2400 at 60 generally gets the overall gearing much better.

Don't worry about going too low for the first gear. My daily driver I use either 1st or 2nd from a stop. Heavy traffic, parking lots, just maneuvering around that low first gear is nice. I used the granny in the 435 (when I had one) in parking lots all the time.

I've thought about the Mazda 5-speed. But the SuperCoupe used the same model transmission and even closer gear spacing. Has the thought of SuperCoupe gears in an F150 case. Don't know if it will work, quick glance says it could.
 

tabyers

Sr. Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2014
Messages
379
Loc.
Indiana
I second, or third? the 5spd of your choosing and 4.56 route. I think gear splits are not to be over looked when considering how you want to get from that low gear to cruising speed. To me, if you don’t want the granny in the 435, okay 2nd is a fine starting point from a stop, but its the gap between 2nd and 3rd that I found hard to deal with. After all, if you don’t use the granny a lot, then you’ve essentially got the stock three speed in there.
 

RonJones

Contributor
Full Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2001
Messages
347
I second the T-19; my version is 5.1:1 in 1st. With stock 3.50 gears and 32.6” diameter tires that gives me:

5 mph, 1st gear: 5.1 * 3.50 * 5 * 336 /32.6 = 920 RPM

75 mph, 4th gear: 1.0 * 3.50 * 75 * 336/32.6 = 2705 RPM

Plus, the trans is built like a tank.

Downside, you know you are shifting a truck!
 

RonJones

Contributor
Full Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2001
Messages
347
From http://www.novak-adapt.com/knowledge/transmissions/manual/t18-t19

“Three gearing options were available for the Ford T19. The T19 was available with a 6.32:1 first gear. These were only in rarer Ford 500-800 series HD trucks. The very most common T19 available in Ford applications was the T19A with the 4:02:1 first gear ratio. For two years (documented from 1983-1986+) there was a Ford T19 option with a 5.11:1 first gear. All ratios listed had a synchronized first.“
 

Attachments

  • 190C78A7-60BB-4B2A-84AC-9E61FAE2545B.gif
    190C78A7-60BB-4B2A-84AC-9E61FAE2545B.gif
    28.3 KB · Views: 97

JSBX

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2010
Messages
652
I had a T-19 in my Broncos for years. Had the 4:02-1 1st gear version. I ran 36" tires with 4:56 gears. It was perfect for my use and I really liked the T-19 but I just got tired of shifting and now going to a 4R70W with 33" tires.
 
Top