I see something that looks off, but I can't say that from any engineering standpoint. Just that it looks wrong.
Your axle shaft is definitely worn Tim. That part is pretty obvious. But it looks like the real wear is where the seal used to ride, and now you can see the black mark just outboard of the wear spot that looks like the seal was riding there.
So far so good. But why in just 100 miles is there any black being left on the shaft in the first place?
I can't say it's wrong, but I can say I've never seen that before.
And looking at the seal itself, why in the heck has it got a hex-shaped inner lip with those hard corner transitions inside the main lip? Never seen that before either.
Looks to me like the seal was either:
1. Too small
2. Softer material that's breaking down already
3. Or has somehow become burned and is loosing it's life right in front of our eyes.
That last likely related to the seal being too tight anyway, so that's really only two things.
But an important aspect of 9" outer seal leaks is to determine whether the leak is at the business end of the seal, on the shaft. Or if it's leaking around the perimeter where many new seals leak from small scratches and gouges in the housing.
If it's leaking from around the outer edge, all you have to do is clean it, dry it, and goop it up with silicone sealer.
If it's the axle shaft edge that's leaking, I would personally change it out for a new one since you have it apart and the current seal looks compromised.
But no matter what, I would certainly smooth down the shaft surface the best you can. Some 400 grit or finer sandpaper is your friend here.
Get the shaft smooth, and trial fit the seal over the surface to see how it feels.
Good luck.
Paul