• Just a reminder that you won't be able to start new posts or reply to existings posts in the Archive forum.

    This is where all the old posts go so they can still be used for reference and searched.
  • Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Enough MIG, which TIG?

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
OK, so we get a new big super fancy Miller TIG welder here at work. I am not even sure what model it is, but make is Miller. I have never TIG'd in my life. Gas welding, at least 12 years. Stick, at least 15. That is not years been doing it, that is years since I tried. MIG I own and am fairly good at.

So I get the 30 second demo. Don't touch the tip. the harder you mash the pedal the hotter it will go. Welds kinda like gas. Fire it up, play with the arc a little, pick up some rod and start having fun. I find myself welding everything, and doing a fairly good job at it as well. By no means an expert, but doing fairly good. Having that pedal on the floor to control the weld, oh so nice. On and off, keeping the weld going, putting heat when and where you want. TIG is amazing.

So now I am thinking of a TIG to add to the garage. I am in the early steps of shopping, not real defined at the moment. Quick check shows MSRP starting at just over $1000, several around $3000, and the upper end of what I could consider home use around $6000.
I am NOT looking to weld nuclear reactors, but I do want AC to do aluminum. The wall power limit is a 220V 50A outlet. This will be a home unit.

My quickie shopping lead my toward a Miller Dyansty 200 SD (the base version of the two shown) http://www.millerwelds.com/products/tig/dynasty_200_series/

So, I am open to thoughts of those running with TIGs. What did you get, why, what do you like, what do you not like, what do you wish you had instead, what was a waste of money, what feature can you not live without, what feature is useless, etc.
 

Skiddy

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 8, 2003
Messages
11,587
I have no idea, but that's pretty good at picking up tig that fast:cool: me trying to use two hands at once might as well have a monkey do it and maybe even look better;D
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
Tig is probably one of the easiest forms of welding one of the best parts is you can always go over the weld one last time with out a rod just to pretty it up. I did a bunch of Tig welding years ago on 1/2" thick stainless steel pipe had to grind out bad factory welds and reweld. It was a piece of cake although the setup was pretty much static no floor control just adjustment on the machine so once it was right you were good to go. Probably the biggest problem is welding out doors when the wind is blowing as the gas will be blown away and cause bad welds.
I've also been considering getting a Tig setup but I'll probably get the add on type kinda depends on what exactly my dads new hobart welder already has havent looked into it yet.
I also want to be able to weld aluminum. I've only done it a few times its a little trickier but not that bad. I seen guys cut a coke can in half and reweld them thats good.
Sorry I'm not much help on suggesting setups.
 

Dave

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 25, 2006
Messages
2,264
I have a Thermal Arc 185 TSW by Thermadyne out of St Louis. The whole package was about $1800. It included everything but the agron cylinder. I bought mine from Airgas. Its 185 Amp AC/DC HF computer controlled. Pedal start, lift start, etc. It's a very nice stick welder too. Small, light, and portable. Easy to set up and use. Get one of those electrode grinders too. Very important for arc stability and control if you want to do weld thin material. I bought it for aircraft repair and fabrication. The MIG gets way more use as setting up the TIG is a bit more involved.



http://www.oxarc.com/desc.ydev?prod_id=10704

Wow! The price has gone up in two years.
 
Last edited:

bronko69er

EB Addict
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
4,599
Loc.
Renton, WA
This is what fuels my welding dreams:

http://www.millerwelds.com/products/tig/syncrowave_250_dx/

Having it watercooled makes a big difference in keeping the torch consistant. My buddy's got one, and it's a really amazing machine.

Thats the one I purchased to use here at work (250DX). Definately a very nice machine. I opted out of the internal recirculating water cooler, saved some money, and plummed into the tap water and ran it out to the drain. The flow requirement is really low so you dont use a lot of water.
 

NicksTrix

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 1, 2001
Messages
6,410
i'm chime in on this one. i'm a tig all the way type of guy.

if it where me.. i'd buy a used machine. somewhere in the 180-250 A range, get it water cooled for sure. i personally have a syncrowave 250 tig runner i use in my shop. it's a great machine, but the problem is i got very spoiled using a dynasty 300 everyday for 7 years. the alum AC is awesome on them, i like the smaller size of the inverter machine and i got real into pulse welding thing material.
the bad thing is they are about 6K.
you can get a 250 for about 1500-2k used and be more than covered for home use.

one machine you might consider is an HTP. pricing is good, but they aren't watercooled. the water cooler is a must imop if you do any bulk work. i don't like hot leads and i think they weld better than an air cooled.

i'm a blue brand type of guy and have used a few others. i've been fortunate to have worked for teams that had blue brand sponsorships so i got spoiled. had to switch to a red brand and there was no comparison.

late last year had the lincoln people here as the company i was working for was potentially going to switch. they shipped in their best machine for us to try out. it didn't come close to the dynasty and asked them how to get their machine to do what the blue one did. they said they couldn't... end of story.


look on ebay, ask your welding supplier for trade ins, look on craigs list... lots of good deals on used stuff out there. just be sure it's not used up.
good luck & enjoy!

sorry i'm long winded today...
 
OP
OP
Broncobowsher

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
Thanks for the input, keep it going.

The one at work is the Miller syncrowave 250 and is water cooled (I remembered to look at the name today). Aluminum is a little tricky as I found out. Impossible if you try it in DC. But after figuring that it needs a lot more amps pushed into it I could lay down som ugly but functional beads in 1/8" stock. Considering I have never welded aluminum ever before, it was looking pretty good. Better then the MIG aluminum welds I have seen.

I am liking the looks of that Thermal Arc 185. I only briefly glanced at it but I do plan to research that one out a lot more. It looks like what I am looking for and a lot more in my price range.

Keep up the info. I would like to see what else people use/like/hate/whatever

I am in no hurry, I have the one at work to pratice with. But I am wanting one at home more and more now that I found out how wel they work
 

77broncoguy

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2004
Messages
501
Loc.
Grand Rapids, MI
I have one of these and love it. It's a little tricky to weld aluminum with it, due to not having ac tig mode, but you can do it. It's a two step process with dc. Price was the biggest factor for me. I sold my old arc welder for $300, and got this with tig torch, arc stinger and ground and gas regulator with hard case for less than $1100

http://www.millerwelds.com/products/tig/maxstar_150_sth/
 
Last edited:

Carl

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 8, 2006
Messages
1,035
Loc.
Aurora, IL
This doesn't really help you out Broncobowsher, but I thought I would share a pic of the TIG welder I have. I got it for next to nothing a couple of years ago and have yet to try it out. I wasn't looking to buy one, it was part of an estate sale lot. It's a water cooled Linde HDA-300. I'm not sure when it was built, but it is huge. It's probably around 4 ft. tall.
 

Attachments

  • Linde1.jpg
    Linde1.jpg
    145.5 KB · Views: 86

NicksTrix

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 1, 2001
Messages
6,410
carl, those older machine usually run really smooht since the electronics are so heavy duty. lots of copper in there. bet it is a heavy piece. good old school transformer machine. it's a keeper for a hobby guy.
 

Carl

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 8, 2006
Messages
1,035
Loc.
Aurora, IL
Good to know NicksTrix. I don't even know how to turn it on. I wouldn't know what to do once I did turn it on.;D
 

fordtrucks4ever

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 8, 2006
Messages
1,280
Loc.
DFW
This doesn't really help you out Broncobowsher, but I thought I would share a pic of the TIG welder I have. I got it for next to nothing a couple of years ago and have yet to try it out. I wasn't looking to buy one, it was part of an estate sale lot. It's a water cooled Linde HDA-300. I'm not sure when it was built, but it is huge. It's probably around 4 ft. tall.


I have that exact welder. Cost only $25 at a machinery auction. Not, IMHO, the best for a welder, but does work. Mine has the selenium rectifiers breaking down. I need to replace them and go with some beefy diodes. Also has a contact switch buzzing that affects the weld quality sometimes. Mine was made in 1970.

My main tig is a Miller Syncrowave 500. Has all the extra bells and whistles. Big enough to weld battleships. Capable of running 1/4" tungsten electrodes. Requires a 200 amp circut tho. OUCH. It was new surplus from a high school shop auction.

I also have a Miller frequency box that attaches to an A/C crackerbox. It will convert over any stick welder to aluminum and welds very well. Its air cooled and for for everything I welded, never had a problem. I cut me teeth on this thing, but its been retired to the storage shelf the last 20 years.
 

Madgyver

Bronco Madman
Joined
Jul 30, 2001
Messages
15,030
Look like Taz responded before me... He's getting pretty savvy on his new PC...

I have been saving up for the Dynasty 200 DX and before that it was the Syncrowave but after seeing and using the Dynasty 200 DX I was set on getting it, this was last year, I started saving $$ from side projects.. This year I go to the welding show again and see a new unit dedicated for TIG and it's half the price of the Dynasty 200.
On top of that I get a little more discount from the sale price so I had to get the Diversion 165... it's still very new for this year and it's not listed on the Miller '08 catalog.
 

Attachments

  • DSC03382.JPG
    DSC03382.JPG
    151.6 KB · Views: 37
  • DSC03385.JPG
    DSC03385.JPG
    146.7 KB · Views: 79
OP
OP
Broncobowsher

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
OK that diversion 165 has peaked my interest. You are right, I didn't see it in the catalog. So I google "Diversion 165 TIG" and a few other versions. What do I get? your report on this welder.

It looks like what I am after, now to find out if another one exists somewhere in the world. Maybe I need to make another run to SEMA this year just for a welder purchase.

I really would like to find the specs on that model, see how it compares. I guess at this poit my 2 biggest questions are 1) HF start? 2) AC for aluminum (I think that is a yes from your other post but I just want to confirm)

Let me guess, I need to make a trip to Hawaii just to pick it up? I think I could do that.
 

ebroncoman

Full Member
Joined
May 6, 2005
Messages
184
Loc.
Denver
I use a Dynasty 200 at work and it's sweeeet! I can plug in anywhere on the production floor to do a repair, from 120v to 480v. It hase the "lift tig" option so you don't have to scratch start, and AC-aluminum settings as well. But, as with all air cooled torches, it (the torch) can get quite warm if you're running at high amperage for a while.
A friend of mine just picked up an old Miller 300 water cooled TIG for $450, but the thing is HUGE!! It weighs 500-600 lbs... That's OK if you have the room for it, and don't need portability. -E
 

BUCKETOBOLTS

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 28, 2003
Messages
1,605
Loc.
Salisbury, NC
Working in an industrial environment there are times to TIG, times to MIG, and times to Stick. We use mostly Ltech/Esab power units for our production line TIG machines. Though there is a pair of Lincoln that are on trial. In our maintenace shop we have a 400 amp Ltech and a new 350 amp Esab. Both have High Frequency AC and adjustable wave which is great for welding aluminum. Also do great on stainless. They are both have a torch for stick welding and really have a clean arc. Downside is that they are 3 phase 480V.

If you are serious about a TIG machine I would suggest that largest machine you can afford with a cooler.

Someone mentioned previously about welding large stainless pipe. When I did some re plumbing in our facility, we stick welded our stainless 8" pipe. The tanks were then MIG welded with a spool gun. Using Trimix gas and stainless wire, it worked well and fairly fast.
 

77broncoguy

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2004
Messages
501
Loc.
Grand Rapids, MI
I'm the fabricator at an ethanol plant here in MI. I have machines to do any type of welding that is needed. But by far the most useful machine is the Maxstar 150 sth. It's easily transported and lightweight. I do all of our stainless piping with this unit (sched. 10) up to and over 36" in diameter. The only time I mig or arc stainless is when it's the heavier schedules. It works great for both mild and stainless, and you can weld aluminum with dc, it just becomes a more tedious process, but it can be done well. I rarely weld aluminum, so for about a grand you get a very versatile machine that can run either 120v or 240v single phase, letting you weld up to 1/2" thick or better. There's no doubt that the larger machines are great, you just have to ask yourself if it's worth the large investment. If you can justify it, more power to you, you'll love them.
 

Madgyver

Bronco Madman
Joined
Jul 30, 2001
Messages
15,030
OK that diversion 165 has peaked my interest. You are right, I didn't see it in the catalog. So I google "Diversion 165 TIG" and a few other versions. What do I get? your report on this welder.

It looks like what I am after, now to find out if another one exists somewhere in the world. Maybe I need to make another run to SEMA this year just for a welder purchase.

I really would like to find the specs on that model, see how it compares. I guess at this poit my 2 biggest questions are 1) HF start? 2) AC for aluminum (I think that is a yes from your other post but I just want to confirm)

Let me guess, I need to make a trip to Hawaii just to pick it up? I think I could do that.
Yes, it is HF, no need to scratch start.. And also it has AC settings for aluminum.

The Maxstar 150 was another unit that I had my eye on but it lacked AC and it is for thinner metals.. I see air condition ducts installers use it in the field when installing SS ducts, it is very portable but they say that it lacks the power..
Dynasty 200 DX is the unit that I wanted but it is expensive and the Diversion 165 does what I need it to do for a TIG and it weighs only 10 pounds more than the Dynasty 200 and costs alot less..
 

Attachments

  • DSC03542.JPG
    DSC03542.JPG
    144.2 KB · Views: 66
  • DSC03551.JPG
    DSC03551.JPG
    123.2 KB · Views: 73
  • DSC03553.JPG
    DSC03553.JPG
    111.7 KB · Views: 73
Top