• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Wrong harmonic balancer?

jcrum

New Member
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
25
But do u think mabey the crank shaft the guy sold me was the newer one. I did not think a newer crank would fit in the older motor.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
Actually the cam solely dictates the firing order, there are zero differences in crankshafts between the two.. Unless you're just making a comparison and included the crank in that.

I was. Mostly because I thought it would help clarify the basic relationship for someone who might be new to the whole inside-the-engine-voodoo thing. And in the very next paragraph, I did mention that the crank did not change in the case of our family of engines. Of course, I used thirty three & a third words to say it, so it might have gotten lost in translation. ;D

So while it would have been technically correct to say it should be thought of as a change in the cam only, I do think it's also technically correct to have defined the basic relationship to be between a cam and a crank together. Even in this instance.

It is after all, at the very basic core of the subject, the direct relationship between both the cam and the crank that defines any firing order in any engine.
Whether talking about just the basics, or actual changes.

Paul
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
That sucks jcrum. To do all that work and end up with a bad vibration.
And yeah, it "could" be a mis-matched crank. But it could be loads of other things as well.

Does it vibrate bad enough that you don't even want to run it? Or do you think you could run it at idle to try to make some other determinations?
For instance, you can verify the correct firing order without running the engine, but it would also be nice to know that each plug is firing.
And possible carburetor or other ignition issues are sometimes easier to diagnose when running.

Without knowing what the crank guy did, it could be the wrong imbalance factor, or it could simply be done wrong from an actual dynamic balance standpoint. Of course, that would be a long-shot for most any shop to have done such a poor job that it's not even drivable.
Is there no way to find out for sure what they did?

And yeah, it's a hijack, but it's possibly related and what the heck. We might all learn something together.
But since yours is sounding to be pretty rich in questions, we should probably start another thread (when you're ready) and we'll dig into it.
You should anyway. Drag up as much info as you can remember and post it up. Sounds interesting!

Paul
 

Ourobos

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 7, 2008
Messages
1,225
Loc.
Big Island Hawaii
I was. Mostly because I thought it would help clarify the basic relationship for someone who might be new to the whole inside-the-engine-voodoo thing. And in the very next paragraph, I did mention that the crank did not change in the case of our family of engines. Of course, I used thirty three & a third words to say it, so it might have gotten lost in translation. ;D

So while it would have been technically correct to say it should be thought of as a change in the cam only, I do think it's also technically correct to have defined the basic relationship to be between a cam and a crank together. Even in this instance.

It is after all, at the very basic core of the subject, the direct relationship between both the cam and the crank that defines any firing order in any engine.
Whether talking about just the basics, or actual changes.

Paul

Now THAT was 33 1/3 words.. LOL
 

Ourobos

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 7, 2008
Messages
1,225
Loc.
Big Island Hawaii
But do u think mabey the crank shaft the guy sold me was the newer one. I did not think a newer crank would fit in the older motor.

302s went to 50oz in 1983 if I remember correctly. The blocks then still used the two piece rear seal until 1985 (if memory serves and I don't use Google).. So I think there was a year or two that the 28oz crank would drop right into the 'newer' blocks and vise versa. Correct me if I'm wrong (I'm sure some will).
 
Top