That sucks jcrum. To do all that work and end up with a bad vibration.
And yeah, it "could" be a mis-matched crank. But it could be loads of other things as well.
Does it vibrate bad enough that you don't even want to run it? Or do you think you could run it at idle to try to make some other determinations?
For instance, you can verify the correct firing order without running the engine, but it would also be nice to know that each plug is firing.
And possible carburetor or other ignition issues are sometimes easier to diagnose when running.
Without knowing what the crank guy did, it could be the wrong imbalance factor, or it could simply be done wrong from an actual dynamic balance standpoint. Of course, that would be a long-shot for most any shop to have done such a poor job that it's not even drivable.
Is there no way to find out for sure what they did?
And yeah, it's a hijack, but it's possibly related and what the heck. We might all learn something together.
But since yours is sounding to be pretty rich in questions, we should probably start another thread (when you're ready) and we'll dig into it.
You should anyway. Drag up as much info as you can remember and post it up. Sounds interesting!
Paul