• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Transmission & transfer case question

Sutcavage

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
19
Loc.
Raleigh
I am looking to swap out my original 3-speed with a 5-speed. Would it be wise to swap in a different transmission and transfer case all together? That way I don't have to drop several hundred dollars on adapter plates and all that stuff. Looking for something to bolt up to the 302 that's in it now.

Thanks
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
Not many options that fit. And trans choice changes the t-case options as well.

If you go with the ZF 5-speed trans, you get to bolt it right up to the engine with no adapters, but you need a transfer case like the NP205 which (I think?) bolts right up.
You would have to fab up a hydraulic clutch, so that adds to the hassle factor, but not a huge increase in money.
And the trans is so large itself that you need a body lift and might still need to modify the tunnel to fit. Lots of them installed in trucks here though, so others will chime in about the relative merits or faults of going with a ZF.

If you go with an NV3550 trans, you could install an NVG 231 or 241 transfer case, but that's about the closest fit of the modern boxes. Most other donor boxes are too wide and not so much an upgrade to be worth it. Even some question about the fitting of the 231's in fact. Not sure who's done it, but I'm going to try it with a Rubicon 241.
There are lots of 231's out there, so price might not be a big factor. But 241's are more scarce, and 4:1 versions even more so. So price goes up accordingly.

An older NP205 is popular with Broncos, so if you get a good deal on one you can get the beef of the 205 that also just fits between the frame rails. Barely...
But it does fit, so is a legit option. Just depends on whether you get the good deal that offsets the cost of adapters for the D20
The downside other than the size, is the taller 2:1 low range, vs the EB's stock 2.4 to 2.6 ratio. Not a deal breaker though, if you don't intend to go off road.

The top dog of course is the Advance Adapters Atlas. But here you're certainly not going to be saving any money over adapters.

I'm sure there are other options I'm not thinking of. Just those are the most obvious off the top of my head.
Cost effectiveness just depends on what you find a good deal on I guess.

Paul
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
Also keep in mind that you'll probably need to regear the axles to make full use of the 5 speed. Few transmission swaps are cheap when all said and done but usually the money you do have to spend is worth the end result
 

sykanr0ng

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 11, 2014
Messages
5,363
Not knowing your planned use of the Bronco it's hard to recommend any transmission or transfer case.

The Bronco has narrower frame rails than most newer 4x4's have, so that is a limit on what fits.

The only 5 speeds for a 4x4 that bolt to a 302 without an adapter are the ZF5 and the M5OD.

What broncnaz says about re-gearing is true, otherwise your RPM will be too low to get any use of the overdrive from the 5 speed.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,114
ZF is a wide ratio 5-speed. Pretty much like driving your old 3-speed but with an extra low 1st gear that really isn't useful on the street outside idling in traffic jams or getting into parking spots. You also get an overdrive, but as mentioned above you need a deep enough axle gear to use it or you will be downshifting on every hill and probably loosing gas mileage when in OD from running too tall of a final drive.

The Mazda is more car like. Does have a weak spot with a rubber plug that falls out and the transmission self destructs by running dry. Easy fix of putting a metal freeze plug in place of the rubber plug and it turns into a pretty OK transmission. A version of this was used in cars, T-bird with the supercharged V6 but that has slightly different gearing and only 2WD.

The NV3550 and AX-15 are even more car like in how they drive, easier clutch setup but more adaptors.

No matter which one you pick there is also the axle gearing and tire size to consider. Drivetrain isn't just a part, it is a package.

What exactly are you trying to accomplish with the 5-speed swap?
What are your personal shortcomings with the 3-speed you have now?
 
OP
OP
S

Sutcavage

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
19
Loc.
Raleigh
What exactly are you trying to accomplish with the 5-speed swap?
What are your personal shortcomings with the 3-speed you have now?

I would like to have a wider range of gear ratios to pick from. It drives me crazy when I'm stuck behind someone slow and 2nd gear is too low and 3rd is too high.
 
OP
OP
S

Sutcavage

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
19
Loc.
Raleigh
Not knowing your planned use of the Bronco it's hard to recommend any transmission or transfer case.

The Bronco has narrower frame rails than most newer 4x4's have, so that is a limit on what fits.

The only 5 speeds for a 4x4 that bolt to a 302 without an adapter are the ZF5 and the M5OD.

What broncnaz says about re-gearing is true, otherwise your RPM will be too low to get any use of the overdrive from the 5 speed.

I mainly just drive it around town and on the highway. But every now and then I'll take it off road. So with the Bronco having narrower frame rails, my options are very limited when it comes to choosing a transfer case that bolts up to those transmission?
 
OP
OP
S

Sutcavage

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
19
Loc.
Raleigh
Also keep in mind that you'll probably need to regear the axles to make full use of the 5 speed. Few transmission swaps are cheap when all said and done but usually the money you do have to spend is worth the end result

I completely looked over that part. So any transmission, regardless I'll still have to regear my axles?
 
OP
OP
S

Sutcavage

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
19
Loc.
Raleigh
Not many options that fit. And trans choice changes the t-case options as well.

If you go with the ZF 5-speed trans, you get to bolt it right up to the engine with no adapters, but you need a transfer case like the NP205 which (I think?) bolts right up.
You would have to fab up a hydraulic clutch, so that adds to the hassle factor, but not a huge increase in money.
And the trans is so large itself that you need a body lift and might still need to modify the tunnel to fit. Lots of them installed in trucks here though, so others will chime in about the relative merits or faults of going with a ZF.

If you go with an NV3550 trans, you could install an NVG 231 or 241 transfer case, but that's about the closest fit of the modern boxes. Most other donor boxes are too wide and not so much an upgrade to be worth it. Even some question about the fitting of the 231's in fact. Not sure who's done it, but I'm going to try it with a Rubicon 241.
There are lots of 231's out there, so price might not be a big factor. But 241's are more scarce, and 4:1 versions even more so. So price goes up accordingly.

An older NP205 is popular with Broncos, so if you get a good deal on one you can get the beef of the 205 that also just fits between the frame rails. Barely...
But it does fit, so is a legit option. Just depends on whether you get the good deal that offsets the cost of adapters for the D20
The downside other than the size, is the taller 2:1 low range, vs the EB's stock 2.4 to 2.6 ratio. Not a deal breaker though, if you don't intend to go off road.

The top dog of course is the Advance Adapters Atlas. But here you're certainly not going to be saving any money over adapters.

I'm sure there are other options I'm not thinking of. Just those are the most obvious off the top of my head.
Cost effectiveness just depends on what you find a good deal on I guess.

Paul

Wow that helps a lot. Thank you very much.
 

Joe473

Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2012
Messages
958
I completely looked over that part. So any transmission, regardless I'll still have to regear my axles?
This depends on your existing tire size and gear ratio. If running 35's and 3.50 gears most definitely. If you already have 4.11's and only running 30x 9.50 and smaller with a good running low torque 302 or 351 it would be ok.

If not running high performance engine, not running off road often, and you can keep your right foot off the floor I would look at M5R2, 4R70W, 3550, or AX15.

You may want to research if a NP205 bolts up to a M5R2 without adapter. If they do this could be cheaper than the rest if you can find good used takeouts.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk
 

bigcountry

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2009
Messages
1,206
Depends on what you want to do with the bronco. You could swap in a m5r2 with an Np205 and not have to use an adapter. You will still need new drive shafts. It is similar to a 3550, and has no low first gear, but it is all Ford.
 

Skiddy

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 8, 2003
Messages
11,587
I would like to have a wider range of gear ratios to pick from. It drives me crazy when I'm stuck behind someone slow and 2nd gear is too low and 3rd is too high.
change the tranny to a C4;)
 

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
I am looking to swap out my original 3-speed with a 5-speed. Would it be wise to swap in a different transmission and transfer case all together? That way I don't have to drop several hundred dollars on adapter plates and all that stuff. Looking for something to bolt up to the 302 that's in it now.

Thanks

Welcome to my favorite forum.

I think that the word "adapter" brings up some thoughts that you're making some sort of funky transition. I reality there the addition of only the bell housing/tranny adapter, since there will always be some sort of adapter between the tranny/transfer case, even from the factory. So I could hardly call it an adapter.
In the case of Advance Adapter's NV3550 tranny/bell housing adapter, it's well thought out and well made.
 

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
I would like to have a wider range of gear ratios to pick from. It drives me crazy when I'm stuck behind someone slow and 2nd gear is too low and 3rd is too high.

Your thought, that more gears to select from will make your car more versatile, are correct. Both the three speed and C4 auto have the same shortcomings. A very high 1st gear and only three gears. If we had a lower 1st gear ratio, and more gears in the tranny, most of us would have never gone to the trouble of installing lower rear end gears and an overdrive tranny.
An overdrive tranny like the NV3550 has a lower 1st gear and a moderate overdrive. Ideally, the rear end ratio needs to be matched to the tire size and tranny ratios to get the most practical use out of both 1st and the overdrive gear of the tranny. Too many are too concerned about the highway performance only. 1st/2nd gear performance are equally important.
Not everyone will agree on any certain gear ratio/tire combination.
You should really to find someone to ride along with to see what you prefer.
 
OP
OP
S

Sutcavage

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
19
Loc.
Raleigh
Welcome to my favorite forum.

I think that the word "adapter" brings up some thoughts that you're making some sort of funky transition. I reality there the addition of only the bell housing/tranny adapter, since there will always be some sort of adapter between the tranny/transfer case, even from the factory. So I could hardly call it an adapter.
In the case of Advance Adapter's NV3550 tranny/bell housing adapter, it's well thought out and well made.

Haha thank you. I'm trying to learn all I can. So in your opinion the adapter is the way to go? Along with the NV3550?
 
OP
OP
S

Sutcavage

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
19
Loc.
Raleigh
Your thought, that more gears to select from will make your car more versatile, are correct. Both the three speed and C4 auto have the same shortcomings. A very high 1st gear and only three gears. If we had a lower 1st gear ratio, and more gears in the tranny, most of us would have never gone to the trouble of installing lower rear end gears and an overdrive tranny.
An overdrive tranny like the NV3550 has a lower 1st gear and a moderate overdrive. Ideally, the rear end ratio needs to be matched to the tire size and tranny ratios to get the most practical use out of both 1st and the overdrive gear of the tranny. Too many are too concerned about the highway performance only. 1st/2nd gear performance are equally important.
Not everyone will agree on any certain gear ratio/tire combination.
You should really to find someone to ride along with to see what you prefer.

Aaahhh okay I see what you mean. Down the road I was planning on upgrading to larger tires (31" on it now) and was prepared to mess with the gear ratios in the axles to accommodate for them. I'd just hate to do it twice. Haha I would love to ride along with someone to see what I prefer but Broncos are hard to come by near me.
 
OP
OP
S

Sutcavage

New Member
Joined
Jan 2, 2017
Messages
19
Loc.
Raleigh
This depends on your existing tire size and gear ratio. If running 35's and 3.50 gears most definitely. If you already have 4.11's and only running 30x 9.50 and smaller with a good running low torque 302 or 351 it would be ok.

If not running high performance engine, not running off road often, and you can keep your right foot off the floor I would look at M5R2, 4R70W, 3550, or AX15.

You may want to research if a NP205 bolts up to a M5R2 without adapter. If they do this could be cheaper than the rest if you can find good used takeouts.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

Right now I just have 31s on it. Alright I'll look into those. Thanks for the info
 

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
Aaahhh okay I see what you mean. Down the road I was planning on upgrading to larger tires (31" on it now) and was prepared to mess with the gear ratios in the axles to accommodate for them. I'd just hate to do it twice. Haha I would love to ride along with someone to see what I prefer but Broncos are hard to come by near me.

Ha!
I was going to invite you to drive mine.
I figured you lived somewhere between Salem and Winston Oregon.
I never knew there was a city with that name.?:?
 

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
Haha thank you. I'm trying to learn all I can. So in your opinion the adapter is the way to go? Along with the NV3550?

Well, that's what I have, but as others have commented, thee are other options.
I'd get onto the Advance Adapter webpage for options. They're the real gurus.
 

Crush

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
May 30, 2007
Messages
3,463
Loc.
Greenbottom, WV
You might find the mazda m5od trans more affordable. They are in f150 trucks from about 87 to now. Ones equipped with 300 6's and 302's. After the mod motors it would be the v-6 models. The newer the trans the better the internals. Also the newest version has the shifter farther back in a better location. You will need the zf d-20 adapter and a twin stick to make it all work. Oh and a custom crossmember and the throwout bearing and hydraulic clut h out of the same truck. Bronco flywheel will work though
 
Top