• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Alternator Question

Sporto

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2005
Messages
923
OK, I am doing some research and thought that I would see what is out there on this...

Is there an externally regulated (like OEM) higher amp alternator that is a bolt in replacement? Meaning, the stock alternator at 65 Amps is okay, but I like the power my 135 Amp 3G puts out. However, I also like having an ammeter and voltmeter. Don't ask...Just know that I am old school, and my father taught me the ways of driving vehicles before idiot lights were invented. ;D

I am thinking about going back to the original configuration to get my ammeter back, or I thought maybe there was higher amperage 2G (or whatever it is called) version that would be a slight upgrade in power, and not require the rework that I did.
I looked around and saw some 70 AMP (Tuff Stuff) alternators, but I was looking for something a little higher than 70.
The OEM 65 Amp alternator was okay, but with EFI and some other improvements, I like having the extra power if needed.

Thanks in advance!

Rich :cool:
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
Nope. What you want is non-existent.
It's not the output, or the bolt-on part. It's the "no rewiring" part. The whole point of getting rid of the ammeter is that the wire can't handle the higher outputs reliably and safely under all circumstances.

I like the ammeter too, and would keep it if possible. But it requires a complete replacement of the 10ga Black w/yellow charge wire with one of at least 8ga to work with a higher amp alternator.

Paul
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
To address the alternator aspect though, it's super easy to upgrade to the large case 1G with up to 105 amps output (stock) or 150-250 amps output (aftermarket) and a few in-between most likely.
The only re-working of the wiring is right at the alternator where you simply change the ends of the Field and Stator wires from their current ring-terminals to flat-blade type terminals. Or better yet, splice in the proper plug-in connector that is still readily available at parts stores and electrical suppliers.

The thing about the ammeter is the wire size. Does not matter if it's coming from an internally or externally regulated alternator (stay away from 2G's at all costs though) because it's the overall output capability that is over the design capability of the original charge wire.
A 10ga wire can handle 150 amps over a couple of feet for a short time, but 10 feet or more of it? Not a chance it would handle it.
I know some that have gotten away with it temporarily because their alternators were never asked to put out their full capacity. But all it takes is one winching session or one long drawn out charge cycle to really ruin your day. And your Bronco...

So the only way to have your cake and eat it too, is to up-size the charge wire.
One way to do it would be to run 6ga from the alternator to a bulkhead connector at the firewall. From there you'd run 8ga through the ammeter loop and back to a second pass-through firewall bulkhead connector. From there you can run another 6ga cable to the battery.

The ammeter itself can handle the current even though it's only rated for 60 amps because it's not a direct-feed that can melt down if too much current is passed through it. It might still not like being pushed to it's mechanical limits, but I don't know what, if any effect that would have on the mechanism. Only that it won't melt directly.

It's just up to you to make sure that the wiring can handle the load for an extended period of time at an excessive rate (safety headroom) in case your big alternator can put out 160 amps (very common with 3G's) or someday the regulator doesn't fail and let the alternator full-field and run amok.

If you think you can do the wiring part (safely), the theory part should cooperate.

Paul
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
Oh, and doing it that way you would likely only see a charge condition. I don't think it would indicate any drain unless you had a load connected to the charge wire behind the ammeter like it does in the stock setup.

Paul
 
OP
OP
Sporto

Sporto

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2005
Messages
923
Thanks Paul,
I need to read through this in detail. One thing to note, I have the Centech harness that has that larger red battery wire that goes through the dash and OEM ammeter loop. I also have the yellow charge wire disconnected and wrapped up in the harness, as that used to be connected to the charging system, and now it just goes back to the fuse panel.

Do you think that red wire and a would handle any increased amperage or not?

Thanks

Rich
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
One thing to note, I have the Centech harness that has that larger red battery wire that goes through the dash and OEM ammeter loop.

That should no longer be able to function as the charge wire. Your ammeter is now non-functioning as far as it goes. Since the Red wire is no longer connected to the alternator in any way (See below) it's only there to power the fuse panel and the accessories. It no longer factors into your charging system.

I also have the yellow charge wire disconnected and wrapped up in the harness, as that used to be connected to the charging system, and now it just goes back to the fuse panel.

That was the wire in question. It and the Red wire are literally the same wire. Well, they're the same circuit at least, even though they are different wires. They are connected end to end either somewhere in the harness, or at the back of the fuse panel.
What do you have connected to the main output post of the alternator now? Is it from the alternator directly to the battery?
If you have something going directly from there to the battery, then the Red wire does not charge the battery, and therefore does not see any amperage other than draw from the accessories. And you ammeter no longer works to show a charge. Have you run the engine with it this way yet? You should not see anything on the ammeter but negative readings. If that...
Unless somehow it's sensing current flow back and forth to both ends of the Red wire, but I'd have to see where they are connected to know. I believe that it comes from the battery, to the ammeter, then to the back of the fuse panel.

Do you think that red wire and a would handle any increased amperage or not?

No. It might be Red and have thick and stiff strands, but it's the same 10 gauge size as stock.
The Centech Red wire will indeed handle more current than the stock alternators will put out, but that's how the stock system is designed anyway. Have to have some safety margin with circuits like this to cover any eventuality without a melt down.
It's just too much of a risk to use such a small wire as a charging circuit for a 3G.
While it "might" live a long and productive life, it might not.

I generally use a 70 amp rating as the recommendation for the largest alternator you should use with the stock or Centech wiring. This means you can use the 65 amp small case 1G alternators, as well as the 70 amp large case 1G alternators. But jump it up to the next level of 95-105 and up, and you need to upgrade the charge cable.
A 95 amp 3G is pushing it, so is not recommended for the 10ga wire.

If you want to know for sure, measure the combined overall length of the Yellow and Red wires in the Centech harness, then find a chart showing how much it's capable of handling per foot. Add some leeway/safety margin, find out what Centech recommends and go with that.
My concern about asking Centech is to determine what the capacity of their fuse panel is. Remember the Red and Yellow wires are interconnected at basically a circuit board. Perhaps it's capable of handling 100+ amps of constant current without concern. Or perhaps not.
At least I think it passes through. I'd have to look at one again and see the current path to be sure, but that's what I remember.

For almost 20 years I've used a great chart on the RBE Electronics site that showed all that good stuff about voltage, amperage, length and wire gauge. But it looks like after all these years it's gone.
Bummer. Now I have to go save another one from someone else. That's ok too, but I really liked their clean format.

The reason to give yourself plenty of headroom in wire size is that any given alternator might be capable of outputting more current than it's actual rating would indicate. So a 70 amp 1G might put out just 70 amps, or it might be capable of 90 amps when pushed. Same for a 3G. I have looked at test cards for 100's of 3G and 4G alternators and not one was less than 10 amps above the rating of 130. Some were 20 amps and more over the top.
So that 3G you get from a rebuilder might just be capable of putting out 150 amps or more. So you have to have some overkill factor into the wiring.

As we've said here before, if there wasn't a safety need for larger wire in a charging circuit, Ford would NEVER pay the difference between the 10ga wire they used to use and 6ga and 4ga cables they use now. And they put that 6ga and 4ga battery cable as the main charge wire on most of their modern cars and trucks.
If they could save 10 cents per car by using smaller wire, you know they would. But they don't, and the savings would likely run into the dollars rather than cents per vehicle. So I figure if Ford thinks a 3G should have 6ga battery cable-sized charge wires, I think we should too.

Again, a 10ga wire is capable of handling a 100 amp flow if it was only a couple of feet long. But since the original wire, and the wires in the Centech harness, are way, way longer than that, it's just better to figure on either using larger wire, or stick with stock-ish alternators.

Paul
 

nvrstuk

Contributor
Just a Bronco driver for over 50 yrs!
Joined
Jul 31, 2001
Messages
10,625
Loc.
PNW
From a safety standpoint, there's no way I'd like to have a 70-100 amp wire cruising thru under my dash amongst all my other wires unless I absolutely HAD to... not worth it. And if you do become so set in this that you do it, isolate this wire from the rest of the harness!!

Ditch the idea, go with the voltmeter in your gauge cluster that looks like the amp meter.

Might sound like I feel strongly about this and I do... don't do it.
 

bronconut73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
9,919
[go with the voltmeter in your gauge cluster that looks like the amp meter]


/\/\This/\/\
 

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
OK, I am doing some research and thought that I would see what is out there on this...

Meaning, the stock alternator at 65 Amps is okay, but I like the power my 135 Amp 3G puts out.

The OEM 65 Amp alternator was okay, but with EFI and some other improvements, I like having the extra power if needed.

Rich :cool:

Just what kind of load are you planning that you'd need 135+ amps?
I guess what I getting at, is there are owners that just want the biggest, without a reason.
These decisions rairly come without a negative side effect.

Even if you don't plan on adding a load, it can happen by itself.
For example, your battery low from sitting with the lights and stereo on with the engine off.
You start the engine with a 60 amp alternator, and it just goes to charging without a problem.
If you start the engine with one of those giant dynamos, and you could get a squealing belt and overheated wiring.
 
OP
OP
Sporto

Sporto

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2005
Messages
923
All,
Thanks for the input. Just to be clear, I have the 135 Amp 3G alternator already installed. I have it connected via the standard diagram that is online with a 4 gauge wire and the Maxi-Fuse etc... routed right to the battery. It is wired safely and functioning properly.

My initial post stems from that fact that I was considering just going back to the original alternator, voltage regulator and ammeter, like I had before. Everything worked fine with the old setup, using the Centech red battery wire through the loop in the back of the gauge. I was thinking that there may be a little bit higher amperage alternator (>65Amps) that still utilizes the external regulator and will not overwhelm the wiring on the Centech harness.

Apparently there are few options that are available or safe from what I am learning, and I have no intention of routing any high amperage current through my dash. I was hoping that something around 100 amps would be available and able to get by, but it appears that is not the case.

I have an external Voltmeter already installed, but like I said in the OP, I am old school and like the ammeter and what it indicates as well. Thus my willingness to downgrade my alternator to get it back. If I did go that direction, I would remove the 3G alternator, and return it to the original wiring as designed. I would just reinstall the OEM 65 amp alternator and call it a day.

With all that said, i do appreciate the insight, concern and knowledge shared after my initial question. I have some thinking to do...There is a noticeable difference in how my Bronco runs with the 3G installed, and I am trying to tell myself that it is just in my melon, but I am not so sure. I don't have a lot of electrical add-ons with the exception of Mustang EFI, HID headlights and some halogen foglights that I don't use very often, but it seems the whole vehicle responds favorably to the added power.

I may just leave it as-is and use the voltmeter and 3G. Trying to bring myself up to the "new ways" ,but it is difficult. :cool:

Thanks again,

Rich
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
I know what you mean. I really don't want to lose the ammeter. No matter what others say about them, I think there is still much to be learned as you drive from an ammeter and a volt-meter working together. And since we don't suffer the same fate as the ammeters that gave them a bad name in the first place, that's not a concern.
Only the size of the wire is the concern.

So yea, you're right there at the max with the 65-70 amps.
Another alternative is to get a Dakota Digital ammeter (don't have a link at the moment) that can be mounted somewhere outside of the cluster. You would use the volt-meter in the cluster, then a separate ammeter.

I think they have both inductive loop type (like our stock ones) and "shunted" that take a reading remotely without having to have the power wire run into the cabin. Might not even be a shunt, but simply a remote inductive loop. I looked at them about six months ago but have lost the links. And with the sheer number of gauges they make now, it might take awhile to find them again.

But it's an option.

Paul
 
OP
OP
Sporto

Sporto

Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2005
Messages
923
WOW! ;D

I researched the Dakota Digital Ammeters, and I think they're the best way to go. I had no idea they existed!

I have their VHX gauge cluster on my list so I may just put the whole thing together that way. I would have a voltmeter and ammeter working together, like you said.

Thanks again for the information Paul!!

Rich
 

bmc69

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 11, 2004
Messages
12,015
For whatever it's worth...the information provided by a voltmeter is far more useful than that provided by an ammeter....one of several reasons why all modern vehicles (including boats) that do have an actual gauge (not just a light) have a voltmeter.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
If you really want an ammeter, find a way to do it with a shunt. Then the high current power doesn't need to come thru the dash. The battery monitor in our camper (Bogart TriMetric) uses a 500 amp shunt in the ground cable to monitor power in and out of the batteries.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
At least some of the ones from Dakota Digital are essentially shunted. You connect the full power, full size wire/cable through the inductive loop on a separate module and then run the standard small sensor wires from the sender to the gauge for the digital readout.
The one I just looked at was rated up to 250 amps, but the gauge itself never sees any of that. Only a signal from the sending unit.

Like most DD sending units/modules though, it doesn't really look like it's intended to spend it's life under the hood. Looks just like any of their other interface modules, but in this case it has a loop on it just like the back of a stock Bronco ammeter.
If that's the case, then I guess you still have to run at least a few inches of the charge wire into the cabin.
Not what everyone wants to see, but not an issue for me.

With the fusible link at one end of the Bronco harness wire (at the starter relay/battery end of the wire) was there ever a fusible link to protect the alternator side? I wonder if there was one built-in to that molded strain relief that was on the back of a stock alternator? You'd think they would have protected both ends of a powered circuit when it was powered at both ends potentially.
If that's the case, then what would be the danger of running the wire through the cabin? Yes, if it melts down then the whole harness goes with it. But what if it was protected from melting down in the first place?

The only one I've ever seen melt was on a '69 with a 150 amp GM alternator conversion performed and all the protection removed. Apparently the person doing the conversion didn't think the fusible link, or any other protection was necessary anymore.%)

Paul
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
There were stock 100 amp 1g alternators but they had larger cases and I'm not sure how well they would fit in a bronco along with the wiring issue if you want to keep the ammeter. I believe they were in lincolns and possibly trucks with camper special pacakges.
There were also kits that you could get to upgrade a small case to 100 amp I have one somewhere in a box.
Not sure a shunt setup would allow the stock loop ammeter to work correctly. Still with the EB wiring its setup to run most power thru the dash.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
No, it would not work in any way that I can see.
You can definitely install the bigger bodied alternator (I have the large-case 1G in both my '71 EB and '79 F-truck) but the 100 amp unit is considered too much for the stock EB wiring. And the full-size truck already has a shunted ammeter. Unlike the EB gauge however, the later full-size ones were notorious for not working at all.

I can't think of how you'd shunt a gauge that's already expecting to see full current flow through it's attached loop. But I'm not an electrical engineer either, so maybe it's an easy thing to do.
I'd rather just run a larger wire, or a remote gauge than figure all that out.

Paul
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
Back to the larger 1G's though, I do believe that they're an upgrade over the stock small-case 1G units. Even if you only opt for the 70 amp model that's only a few amps more powerful than a small-case 1G with 65 amps.
In all the ones I've done they just seem to last longer and are generally accepted to put out more power at lower rpm than the ones that came in our trucks. Maybe they just run cooler? I don't know, but I think at least one of the bearings is larger as well.

And they do fit Broncos almost like you'd expect a regular one to. In one install I had to lengthen the slotted hole in the lower support/adjusting bracket a 1/4" or so to let the belt tension. But with the availability of so many fractional size variations in belt length, you don't always need to do even that.
Otherwise it just bolts right in.

Wiring-wise, the only thing you need to change is the type of connector. Otherwise all the wires just remain stock with the 70 amp model.
Upgrading to the 105 or higher amp units would be just like putting a 95 or higher amp 3G in though. You would still want to change to the larger charging cable directly to the battery.

So while a 70 amp version seems to be no problem, a 105 amp or more version would need the upgraded wire.
The interesting thing about wire gauge sizes and capacities though, is that if you literally just changed the wire size in the engine compartment and left the rest as 10ga, you would probably be able to handle 125-150 amps pretty securely with the, now much shorter, 10ga wire under the dash.
As I know you know, it's all about the length. Or in other words... Size does matter.

I'd still change it if I wanted the stock ammeter and a 100+ amp alternator though. Just to make sure it's all new and in good shape. But no matter what method I used, I'd make sure it's protected at both ends inside the engine compartment. That way nothing that happens outside, whether an overcharging alternator or a short-circuit, would create any problems with the rest of the wiring.

Paul
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
As I understand the workings of ammeters they are basically a very low voltage reading voltmeter. The voltage that they sense is either the tiny voltage drop across the very small resistance of a shunt (V = I/R) or it is a tiny voltage induced in a coil wrapped around a conductor. In either case the polarity of the voltage will vary with the direction of the current. The calibration of the meter for one type of current sensor probably won't work for the other type, but it may well be that the calibration can be changed to match the type of voltage generation by someone sufficiently knowledgable.

If you broaden your research spectrum and look at any of the Big 3's HD alternator options for Fleet service, Police cars, etc. the alternator case is almost always a bigger one than the std. alternator case.

In GM stuff, look for the 17si series. They're huge cases, but only rated starting at about 100 amps. With the larger stator OD that a larger case allows it doesn't have to spin as fast to put out as many amps as does a smaller cased alternator.
MISF puts a 17 on all of his vehicles. The one on the Scout likely got hopped-up, but I suspect the one on his DD was left at ~100 amps because '69 Gran Prix's don't have much need for a winch.
 
Top