• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Gear selection

Gear selection

  • 4.56

    Votes: 3 12.5%
  • 4.88

    Votes: 9 37.5%
  • 5.13

    Votes: 12 50.0%

  • Total voters
    24

gunnibronco

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
Messages
628
Loc.
Gardnerville, NV
It's time to choose gears.
Back ground, mostly crawling but want to be able to drive to most trails (1-2 hr max travel time).
37's, 302 with Mustang EFI, ZF-5 speed. Atlas 4 speed (2.7:1, 4.3:1, 11.7:1),so crawling gears aren't even a considerations. I'm running 3.5 gears and have everything I want offroad.
Chart below is based on the following:
2300-2900 RPM is ideal.
2200 RPM is marginal on the low end- I can still accelerate to higher RPMs on hills, below this I can't.
3000 RPM is marginal on the high end- It's ok, but feels like I don't want to hang around or go much higher. Maybe I'm a wimp, feel free to tell me I'm wrong

How much of a concern is the strength of gears compared to the gear ratio? I've been told the higher gear ratios are weaker. Is this a real issue? Some of the club members (running big gear ratios and tires) said this is outdated info and not a real big concern.

Looking for input. Bonus points if you are running a similar set up.
 

Attachments

  • Gears-MPH.PNG
    Gears-MPH.PNG
    22.8 KB · Views: 123
  • KIMG0085.jpg
    KIMG0085.jpg
    86.1 KB · Views: 74
  • KIMG0086.jpg
    KIMG0086.jpg
    118.6 KB · Views: 69
  • KIMG0087.jpg
    KIMG0087.jpg
    107.8 KB · Views: 74
Last edited:

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
I would even consider 5.38s as a viable option.

Tall tires and overdrive transmission on a vehicle with horrible aero and high rolling resistance. Takes gears to lighten the load on the engine and be in the power.

For reference I was last running 4.88 gears with 33s, but overdrive was a different ratio in the 4R70W (0.70:1). I had a little better torque with a 351. But I recalled that combo would have been perfect if it was only a 5.0 engine.

I like my overdrive geared so I can pull most highway grades in overdrive. So true with a stick shift. Even my daily driver that is a stick and is 100% stock is this way. I may not have much reserve in overdrive, but it will pull it. Drop a gear (or two) only on the bigger stuff. Much easier to drive. Much more comfortable.

I'm guessing your highway driving now is between 3rd and 4th gear? Hard to even think of how it drives with that much tire and that tall of a gear.
 
OP
OP
gunnibronco

gunnibronco

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
Messages
628
Loc.
Gardnerville, NV
I would even consider 5.38s as a viable option.

Tall tires and overdrive transmission on a vehicle with horrible aero and high rolling resistance. Takes gears to lighten the load on the engine and be in the power.

For reference I was last running 4.88 gears with 33s, but overdrive was a different ratio in the 4R70W (0.70:1). I had a little better torque with a 351. But I recalled that combo would have been perfect if it was only a 5.0 engine.

I like my overdrive geared so I can pull most highway grades in overdrive. So true with a stick shift. Even my daily driver that is a stick and is 100% stock is this way. I may not have much reserve in overdrive, but it will pull it. Drop a gear (or two) only on the bigger stuff. Much easier to drive. Much more comfortable.

I'm guessing your highway driving now is between 3rd and 4th gear? Hard to even think of how it drives with that much tire and that tall of a gear.

Good input.

I was expecting worse performance pulling highways speeds/low rpms than I've seen. But I also moved 3000' lower between changing from 33s to 37s. So I've got a bit more power due to lower elevation.

Yes I'm running mostly in 3rd gear. I can only shift to 4th once up to highway speed, and only if it's flat. Getting into the mountains, the gearing problems become more evident. It's unlivable. I knew this was going to happen. The truck has only been on the road with this set up for a few weeks. I was *hoping* I could live with it, but obviously I can't.
 

JSBX

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2010
Messages
652
I have a similar set up in my trail rig. 5.0, Mustang EFI, 2 speed atlas, 5.13 gears and 37's but a 4R70W. It pulls hills in overdrive with no problems and is not screaming at high way speeds. I swapped from 4.56 to 5.13 gears and have no regrets.
 
OP
OP
gunnibronco

gunnibronco

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
Messages
628
Loc.
Gardnerville, NV
I have a similar set up in my trail rig. 5.0, Mustang EFI, 2 speed atlas, 5.13 gears and 37's but a 4R70W. It pulls hills in overdrive with no problems and is not screaming at high way speeds. I swapped from 4.56 to 5.13 gears and have no regrets.

Thanks, great info.
 

lars

Contributor
Been here awhile
Joined
Jun 29, 2001
Messages
3,334
Loc.
NorCal flatlands
I would even consider 5.38s as a viable option.

Tall tires and overdrive transmission on a vehicle with horrible aero and high rolling resistance. Takes gears to lighten the load on the engine and be in the power.

For reference I was last running 4.88 gears with 33s, but overdrive was a different ratio in the 4R70W (0.70:1). I had a little better torque with a 351. But I recalled that combo would have been perfect if it was only a 5.0 engine.

I like my overdrive geared so I can pull most highway grades in overdrive. So true with a stick shift. Even my daily driver that is a stick and is 100% stock is this way. I may not have much reserve in overdrive, but it will pull it. Drop a gear (or two) only on the bigger stuff. Much easier to drive. Much more comfortable.

I'm guessing your highway driving now is between 3rd and 4th gear? Hard to even think of how it drives with that much tire and that tall of a gear.

^^^This

Mine was NV4500/4.56/35" tires (that part still is), driven by an Explorer 5.0 with some mods. Speaking directly to crossing the Sierras numerous times enroute to various adventures, going up Iron Mountain Road (for example) loaded down with camping gear was 4th gear, occasionally 3rd. But in general that gearing was tractable. Just marginal in heavy load/high altitude situations. Going over Donner Pass required only a few shifts into 4th.

Just replaced the 5.0 with a 408, was thinking I'd be wanting 4.10 gears instead. Nope. Lots more low end torque but it just means not shifting into 4th as often.

Given your engine/gears/altitude no way I'd go less than 5.13.
 

Apogee

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 26, 2005
Messages
6,348
Loc.
Tangent, OR
I agree with most of the posts above, and I'd do 5.13's with your setup given the 302. I personally run 4.88's with 37's/351W/NV4500 and it's good on the calculators (haven't run it yet), but presumably making more torque than your 302 everywhere. At the end of the day, anything 4.56 to 5.38 is going to be night and day better than the 3.50's you have now on the street.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,650
How much of a concern is the strength of gears compared to the gear ratio? I've been told the higher gear ratios are weaker. Is this a real issue? Some of the club members (running big gear ratios and tires) said this is outdated info and not a real big concern.

I'm not sure it's outdated. It's still an issue with Dana axles. Your Ford 9" rear end does not suffer this degradation, but the Dana fronts do. The lower the gear (higher the number) the smaller the pinion gear gets.
Big tires, small gears, equals potential breakage. At some point it just depends on your right foot and how well you think things through before tackling them.

I know people who've broken pinion gears within half an hour on the trail in Moab. But in both cases the driver's were lead-foot Lenny's with 37's. When they had 35's and taller gearing, they could not have as much fun, but tried anyway and did not break. When one of them changed to 37's he did not break either, but couldn't get out of his own way. Literally the Jeep was a pig. I drove it to the meeting point at the fairgrounds just outside of town at the Jeep Safari and it barely made the low hill on the highway.
Changed to lower gearing and broke it the next time out.

So while maybe it's not as common as it used to be, likely due to more robust components, reinforcing the assemblies, careful application of the go pedal, and luck... I doubt that it has become "nothing to be concerned about" quite yet.

Now this is coming from someone who's never broken a driveline component, so probably is not the best judge of what you can get away with. But I doubt the problem has simply gone away.

Paul
 

Apogee

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 26, 2005
Messages
6,348
Loc.
Tangent, OR
Do I spy an HP D44 at F150 width? Reverse cut gears with a high-pinion will certainly help your gear strength/reliability, but it's never going to be a HP D60.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
1972 Bronco, explorer motor with 4R70W and 31 inch tires is happy at 2000 rpm's with 4:56's.

I am sure it is. Not far off the 4.88 and 33s I was running with a 4R70W.

But 37s are a whole new level of drag at highway speeds. Aero is a tough one to fight. And the overdrive on a ZF is going to be a bit different as well.
 
OP
OP
gunnibronco

gunnibronco

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
Messages
628
Loc.
Gardnerville, NV
Do I spy an HP D44 at F150 width? Reverse cut gears with a high-pinion will certainly help your gear strength/reliability, but it's never going to be a HP D60.

Yes, 79 Bronco axles. I have an early 76/77 housing that will be part of the gear and locker swap. Along with a set of chromo axles and CTM ujoints.

I understand I'm right at the limits of a D44, that is why I'm worried about gear strength.

From the few trail runs I've done with the Atlas4, and speaking with another A4 owner, it really gives a lot of control and keeps you off the skinny pedal. So I hope I can make it survive. My goal is that the weak points will be trail serviceable (1310 ujoints/hubs). I know it's not a perfect plan, but with 11.7:1 gearing, I figure I can break something with any set of axles/driveshafts. There will always be a fuse in a system.

If/when I upgrade motors I'll be upgrading axles. My Atlas ZF swap (and a lot of other upgrades) took way too long and I want to drive the truck. It's no fun just working on it. I don't want to talk about upgraded axles, etc at this point. I need to enjoy the truck for what I built it to do before I hate it and don't want to work on it anymore.
 
OP
OP
gunnibronco

gunnibronco

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
Messages
628
Loc.
Gardnerville, NV
I'm not sure it's outdated. It's still an issue with Dana axles. Your Ford 9" rear end does not suffer this degradation, but the Dana fronts do. The lower the gear (higher the number) the smaller the pinion gear gets.
Big tires, small gears, equals potential breakage. At some point it just depends on your right foot and how well you think things through before tackling them.

I know people who've broken pinion gears within half an hour on the trail in Moab. But in both cases the driver's were lead-foot Lenny's with 37's. When they had 35's and taller gearing, they could not have as much fun, but tried anyway and did not break. When one of them changed to 37's he did not break either, but couldn't get out of his own way. Literally the Jeep was a pig. I drove it to the meeting point at the fairgrounds just outside of town at the Jeep Safari and it barely made the low hill on the highway.
Changed to lower gearing and broke it the next time out.

So while maybe it's not as common as it used to be, likely due to more robust components, reinforcing the assemblies, careful application of the go pedal, and luck... I doubt that it has become "nothing to be concerned about" quite yet.

Now this is coming from someone who's never broken a driveline component, so probably is not the best judge of what you can get away with. But I doubt the problem has simply gone away.

Paul

All good info. Without the 5.72 first gear of the ZF, I couldn't get the Bronco to move. It's driveable, but barely.

I was leaning towards the 4.56s to start (and not use OD) due to the "higher gears are weaker gears" issue. I have heard from many that is not the issue it used to be. Of course the fact is the higher gears ARE weaker, but hopefully something else in my system is weaker than the gears (1310 ujoints, hubs, etc). As I said above, with my combo I think I could break something in any set up.

From everywhere I've posted (Colorado Classic Broncos, FB, here), I've seen a few people who like their 4.88s with a similar combo as mine. I've seen a few people who have 4.88s and wish they had gone with 5.13s. I haven't seen anyone who regrets going with 5.13s. So I'm leaning that direction despite the "weaker gear" issue.

I live at 4700' elevation, live about 4 miles from the Sierras (South Lake Tahoe area) and so mountain drivability is important. I don't want to trailer everywhere I wheel.
 
OP
OP
gunnibronco

gunnibronco

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
Messages
628
Loc.
Gardnerville, NV
1972 Bronco, explorer motor with 4R70W and 31 inch tires is happy at 2000 rpm's with 4:56's.

I lived with my 3.5 gears with no OD (NP435) on 33s for a long time (at 8000'+ elevation) but it was a dog at highway speed. I'm 3000' lower, but with 37s and an OD now, so it's a whole new ball game.
 
OP
OP
gunnibronco

gunnibronco

Contributor
Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
Messages
628
Loc.
Gardnerville, NV
I agree with most of the posts above, and I'd do 5.13's with your setup given the 302. I personally run 4.88's with 37's/351W/NV4500 and it's good on the calculators (haven't run it yet), but presumably making more torque than your 302 everywhere. At the end of the day, anything 4.56 to 5.38 is going to be night and day better than the 3.50's you have now on the street.

If I had a 351 I would be looking at 4.56 & 4.88. Lots of guys I know with 37s & 351s on those gears. It's a WAY better truck motor than the 302.
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
I'll just throw the reminder out there...
Build the 9" first and go for a drive. If you don't like it, not that big of a deal to regear again. Sell some lightly used gears for a small loss and an evening setting up the 9" again. Once you do the front you have a LOT of money tied up in gears.
 

bigmuddy

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 28, 2004
Messages
8,071
Loc.
Marthasville Missouri
I'll just throw the reminder out there...
Build the 9" first and go for a drive. If you don't like it, not that big of a deal to regear again. Sell some lightly used gears for a small loss and an evening setting up the 9" again. Once you do the front you have a LOT of money tied up in gears.


This right here...
 

Apogee

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 26, 2005
Messages
6,348
Loc.
Tangent, OR
The difference between 4.88's and 5.13's is only 5%, so it's not a huge change and if that makes or breaks the drivability of a rig, you're cutting things a bit close in too many ways IMO. While I may prefer that I went with 5.13's once mine is back on the road, the 4.88's should be totally usable and at that point you're just splitting hairs. I liked the shift points with my setup better with the 4.88's and I figured if I ever ditched the manual for an auto, the 4.88's were a better choice given the additional advantage of a torque converter.
 

lars

Contributor
Been here awhile
Joined
Jun 29, 2001
Messages
3,334
Loc.
NorCal flatlands
The difference between 4.88's and 5.13's is only 5%, so it's not a huge change and if that makes or breaks the drivability of a rig, you're cutting things a bit close in too many ways IMO. While I may prefer that I went with 5.13's once mine is back on the road, the 4.88's should be totally usable and at that point you're just splitting hairs. I liked the shift points with my setup better with the 4.88's and I figured if I ever ditched the manual for an auto, the 4.88's were a better choice given the additional advantage of a torque converter.

Apropos of nothing, I'm glad you posted. Simply so I could read your amusing signature line again.
-Spoken as an engineer who gets it...
 
Top