• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

Consensus on aluminum radiators

turbotim2

Contributor
____________
Joined
Jun 26, 2003
Messages
2,158
After reading a bunch of posts, it seems like the consensus is to stay away from aluminum radiators?

I am ok with copper/brass, I am still running a stock 3 core in front of a mildly built 351.

Considering a change during tear down later this year.
 

BroncoJimbo

Contributor
Long-term owner
Joined
Jun 11, 2014
Messages
291
Loc.
North GA
I've been using them but only due to the cost of a new copper/brass. They are pretty, fit reasonably well but, don't last very long.
 

AZ73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Mar 28, 2012
Messages
3,813
They don't do well with any kind of flex. Copper is more forgiving when flexing. In the old days aluminum was lighter and more efficient so people used them to save weight and keep cool. Nowadays most copper radiators are "desert" radiators. More fins. They're heavier but similar efficiency. Plus you can braze them anywhere. You get a leak in Aluminum when you're out on the trail and there's no repair.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
I recall a post here about comparing the thermal efficiency of the two different types. By itself aluminum transfers heat better than copper or brass does, but the solder used on copper to assemble the whole radiator is better than the braze used to assemble an aluminum radiator. The net result being that their overall actual thermal transfer rates are about the same.

Aluminum corrodes easier than copper, and it can set up a bad galvanic corrosion "battery." Many here have had this occur. Some were able to solve the problem, others who did exactly the same thing were not able to. I've concluded that the OEM use of plastic tanks is not simply a cost based decision. It is also driven by Engineering dielectric needs.
Galvanic Corrosion Link
Just now, really looking at the link I realized that AL is "less Noble" than iron where copper is more "Noble." What this means is that with an aluminum radiator it is the galvanic corrosion focus, but with a copper/brass radiator the iron block & cyl heads are the galvanic corrosion focus. Explains to me why rust on an AL radiator system is far less common, IME, than it is in a copper/brass radiator system.
 

bigmuddy

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 28, 2004
Messages
8,071
Loc.
Marthasville Missouri
This wasn't the thread that I said I would post this too as I can't find it, but ntsqd I had said I would post this cap and lanyard type anode. Probably going to stick it in several threads for posterity, and I haven't checked to see if they are still available for sale?
 

Attachments

  • Alum rad cap with anode.jpg
    Alum rad cap with anode.jpg
    53.6 KB · Views: 171

Timmy390

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Messages
5,948
Loc.
Conway, AR
After reading a bunch of posts, it seems like the consensus is to stay away from aluminum radiators?
I have to disagree......way too many factors to say "stay away from" All OEM rads are plastic and aluminum and have been for many many many years.

Now the issue with Bronco rads is the vast different way Broncos are used. I can tell you my drive it hard all the time on the street bronco that looks VERY offroad capable (some would call it rough) has had 2 aluminum rads in the past 10 years. First one was name brand. It leaked from day one of install. The leak got so bad I swapped it out in a pinch with a cheap eBay aluminum rad. It's been 2 or 3 years now with no issues. Keeps my mild W cool and no leaks. I'm happy with it. When it fails I will order another. OR maybe I'll do the Explorer rad swap. They're cheap and parts stores have them.

For street use IMO aluminum is fine. For hard offroading maybe not.....but maybe so. Offroading is a relative term.

Tim
 

bigmuddy

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Dec 28, 2004
Messages
8,071
Loc.
Marthasville Missouri
I have to disagree......way too many factors to say "stay away from" All OEM rads are plastic and aluminum and have been for many many many years.

Now the issue with Bronco rads is the vast different way Broncos are used. I can tell you my drive it hard all the time on the street bronco that looks VERY offroad capable (some would call it rough) has had 2 aluminum rads in the past 10 years. First one was name brand. It leaked from day one of install. The leak got so bad I swapped it out in a pinch with a cheap eBay aluminum rad. It's been 2 or 3 years now with no issues. Keeps my mild W cool and no leaks. I'm happy with it. When it fails I will order another. OR maybe I'll do the Explorer rad swap. They're cheap and parts stores have them.

For street use IMO aluminum is fine. For hard offroading maybe not.....but maybe so. Offroading is a relative term.

Tim
Good points, there is a local buddy that has killed several aluminum radiators and finally after speaking with one of the manufactures came up with a different mounting system that allowed more rubber isolators and to accommodate more flexing when offroad. He hasn't had any issue again since going to a this different and more flexible mounting system.
 

toddz69

Sponsor/Vendor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 28, 2001
Messages
11,222

Lawndart

Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2014
Messages
958
Loc.
66030
Al gets a NO vote from me.
Spent a bunch of $$ on a nice Griffin, fittings for the trans cooler, etc. Leaked within a year.
Back to a original reman from Orielly's... 50k miles later and no leaks.
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
Just take your stock one to a reputable local shop and have em put a good quality core in it
In my area that is a challenge all by itself. Most of them have closed.

Semi-related: Heater core in Snowball died on the way to work this morning. That is the second one I've put in this truck since buying it in '19. Aluminum cores appear to be the only option. Tempted to try the $100 FoMoVo option if it means that I don't have to do this again. Time for a coolant service anyway....
 

Timmy390

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Messages
5,948
Loc.
Conway, AR
Semi-related: Heater core in Snowball died on the way to work this morning. That is the second one I've put in this truck since buying it in '19. Aluminum cores appear to be the only option. Tempted to try the $100 FoMoVo option if it means that I don't have to do this again. Time for a coolant service anyway....
How about this one?
https://tomsoffroad.com/products/66...gBMUuFMondi3ufIc_a7deJUPyaqnZP7kaAsGFEALw_wcB

Or
https://www.jegs.com/i/JEGS/555/760...LriEji7RBlPiUb8ETmSylqycgWgn8WL4aAquwEALw_wcB

Tim
 

ntsqd

heratic car camper
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
5,970
Loc.
Upper SoKA
[HIJACK]'96 MY, would need this one: https://www.jegs.com/i/JEGS/555/76062/10002/-1?year=1996&make=FORD&model=BRONCO but its AL and suffers from what I'm beginning to think is a design problem that all of them have. Note how the tubes on it are connected to the end tanks.
Compare/contrast that with the FoMoCo core here: https://www.npdlink.com/product/heater-core/130372
There is nothing that really supports the tubes when you're pushing the hoses onto them, or supports them while in use. Last two both failed at one of those connections, am betting this one did too.[/HIJACK]
 

Timmy390

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Messages
5,948
Loc.
Conway, AR
There is nothing that really supports the tubes when you're pushing the hoses onto them, or supports them while in use. Last two both failed at one of those connections, am betting this one did too.
Yup....my tubes broke when taking the hoses off. In Arkansas I don't really need a heater so it's been disconnected for years. Not having a defrost is a pain si I carry a shimmy to wipe the windshield.

Tim
 

Broncobowsher

Contributor
Total hack
Joined
Jun 4, 2002
Messages
37,112
Aluminum can live. They key is mount them so the float. Mount rigid, they flex, they will fail. Brass will as well but generally takes longer. Any modern aluminum radiator is mounted is squishy rubber. Body can flex, radiator does not.
Epoxy where the tubes meet the header was frowned upon. But is generally a good idea. The actual seal is done by brazing, the epoxy is a strain relief at the joint.
top and bottom headers sawn is a good thing. They expand at different rates than the tubes. The cut lines remove the stress where the tubes meet the tanks
 
Top