• Welcome to ClassicBroncos! - You are currently viewing the forums as a GUEST. To take advantage of all the site features, please take a moment to register. It's fast, simple and absolutely free. So please join our community today!
    If you have problems registering or can't log into your account, please contact Admin.

28 vs 31 Spline question

hardy1720

New Member
Joined
Dec 13, 2015
Messages
37
Loc.
Rome GA
Hi! I am new to the bronco restoration world and I am in need of some advice/help!! Thanks in advance!

1. 1976 ford 9" rear, large bearing. It currently has 28 spline axles. In order to upgrade to 31 spline, will I have to change the housing? I will be running 31x10.5r15 tires on a 2.5 lift, so is the upgrade/expense even justified? Mainly paved road use with a little trail/farm usage.

2. If you do upgrade the rear, is it recommended to upgrade the front to 31 spline as well? My front is a 1976 dana 44 with 28 spline/4.11 gears. My understanding is I would have to change the housing in order to accomplish this!?! Again, is this recommended or a waste of money?

Thanks
Chris
 

bronconut73

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 7, 2012
Messages
9,919
I ran 33's pretty hard, as a teen age driver, for twenty plus years with 28 spline axles.
I say leave them alone with your 31's and intended use.
 

sykanr0ng

Bronco Guru
Joined
Aug 11, 2014
Messages
5,363
Hi! I am new to the bronco restoration world and I am in need of some advice/help!! Thanks in advance!

1. 1976 ford 9" rear, large bearing. It currently has 28 spline axles. In order to upgrade to 31 spline, will I have to change the housing? I will be running 31x10.5r15 tires on a 2.5 lift, so is the upgrade/expense even justified? Mainly paved road use with a little trail/farm usage.

2. If you do upgrade the rear, is it recommended to upgrade the front to 31 spline as well? My front is a 1976 dana 44 with 28 spline/4.11 gears. My understanding is I would have to change the housing in order to accomplish this!?! Again, is this recommended or a waste of money?

Thanks
Chris

The 9 inch housing will not need changed.
The 9 inch third member should work, though the bearings will likely be different.

The Dana 44 stock spline count in all early Broncos is 30 for the inner carrier end and 19 at the locking hubs.
To upgrade that to a higher count would require a different carrier, the housing could be kept the same.

For your intended use the 28 spline axles in the rear are strong enough, as are the stock size front shafts.
There is no need to change them.
Waste of time and money.
 

Skiddy

Bronco Guru
Joined
Oct 8, 2003
Messages
11,587
The 9 inch housing will not need changed.
The 9 inch third member should work, though the bearings will likely be different.

The Dana 44 stock spline count in all early Broncos is 30 for the inner carrier end and 19 at the locking hubs.
To upgrade that to a higher count would require a different carrier, the housing could be kept the same.

For your intended use the 28 spline axles in the rear are strong enough, as are the stock size front shafts.
There is no need to change them.
Waste of time and money.
X3 I ran 28 for a while with spool and 35's. I upgrade when I started bouncing off rocks lol. some of guys I wheel with still run 28 splines and are not easy on them hold up pretty good.
 

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
The rear 9" housing can be used with either 28 or 31 spline axles. The carrier needs to be changed if you decide to use 31 spline axles.
The accepted threshold for 28 spline axles has been 35" tires. Under that and your axles should be ok.
 

broncnaz

Bronco Guru
Joined
May 22, 2003
Messages
24,342
1. Housing doesn't need to be upgraded. unless you have a small bearing housing which I don't believe they had in 76. You should have a big bearing rear. but the differential has to be upgraded to accept 31 spline shafts.
2. I don't think there is a 28 spline D44. standard is 30 spline. no reason to upgrade there for your useage. not even sure there is a upgrade for the 44 and if there is you don't need it anyhow.

As was said with only 31in tires and your intended useage you should be fine. upgrading the rear to 31 spline is a good upgrade but can cost anywhere from about $350 on the cheap side to over $1K if you upgrade to a locker. You can get stronger alloy 28spline axles that are supposed to e about 28% stronger than stock but they are probably not really worth it unless you have limited slip or a locker already and just wanted stronger axles without spending a lot of money.
Like the previous poster Ive ran 31's and 33's and do a fair amount of wheeling on 28spline axles for years. Maybe one day I'll upgrade but its way down the list for now.
 

Brent13

Sr. Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2015
Messages
673
Loc.
Colorado Springs
Good the hear! I am in the middle of R&P swap right now. I did add a 28 spline Yukon Grizzly, and obviously keeping my 28 spline axles. I am on a 33" tire, and am building a, let's say, medium duty trail rig. Nothing extreme in my trail riding future, I plan to keep to the lesser Colorado trails. I don't care to really tear up the truck. 31 spline would be overkill for me.
 

broncodriver99

Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 27, 2008
Messages
4,780
Loc.
Glen Allen, VA
Just stick with the stock 28 spline. Many people have run them for many years with 33-35+" tires with no problems.You will be fine with 31's.
 

tabyers

Sr. Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2014
Messages
379
Loc.
Indiana
I feel the same way. I've had my truck since I was 18 and I've ruined almost everything on it over the years. Ive never had any trouble with the 28. I think if you're rock crawling with 37s or something like that, but I've even snapped the yoke off my 9" before, completely obliterated my Dana 30, and snapped both axle shafts in my 44 and had to replace with oversized chromoly. Rear axle shafts have been fine the whole time.
 

B RON CO

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jun 29, 2016
Messages
2,484
Loc.
Statesville, NC
Hi, as mentioned, you have the biggest most heavy duty stock Ford rear end of it's day. It will take what you dish out. Most of us have gone through the wheel bearings. Not a big deal after all these years. By the way, my 76 rear came with traction loc (posi) and 3.50 gears. I thought 3.50 gears were normal. Jack it up and turn the tire 1 full turn, and count how many revolutions the drive shaft makes. That will tell you the gear ratio. Also if both rear tires spin the same way you have a posi rear, if they spin opposite ways you have an open rear. Good luck
 

Timmy390

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Messages
5,948
Loc.
Conway, AR
I would upgrade to 31 spline if you're buying a locker or something but otherwise your fine.

This ^^^ and I'll also say if you're going with a 351W and any type of locking devise including a limited slip. I drive my rig hard on the street.

I didn't brake an axle but I split a 4 pin T-loc in half with my 351W stock 3 speed and 4.11 gears. I'm now running 31 spline axles and Eaton Tru-Track. Currently have 32's (measure out at 31 almost no tread left) but going 33/34's soon.

Tim
 

Rustytruck

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
10,872
I would bet most of the surviving Broncos still have their original 28 spline axles. What they shouldn't have after 40 years is their original rear axle bearings. I run with my original 28 spline axles and bearings with 33" tires and Detroit locker. the Detroit was installed 25 years ago or so. I have played hard but not excessively abused it too much.
I have the bearings on the shelf but its been on the to do list for quite a while. If I had to replace the whole axle then I would still buy a modern heavy duty axle with better steel they are about 25% stronger than stock and our vendors carry them. The 31 inch spline axles with modern steel are probably another 25% stronger than the better 28 spline axles but you have to convert to 31 spline differential stuff too. If I were planning to do a 100,000 mile daily driver I would probably replace the axle and bearings to get rid of the 40+ years of fatigue in the old axles.

The fronts the axles are OK for what you plan just don't crank the steering all the way over and use power in 4 WD low. Cranking hard over and powering in 4 low is a good way to shatter the u-joint in the front axle. If you ever replace the axle especially the short side use a better axle with the larger Chevy size u-joint. These stock axles I broke fairly easily on the short side but upgrading the axle I haven't broke yet but i am also older and wiser these days.
 

DirtDonk

Contributor
Bronco Guru
Joined
Nov 3, 2003
Messages
51,651
Good the hear! I am in the middle of R&P swap right now. I did add a 28 spline Yukon Grizzly, and obviously keeping my 28 spline axles...

Well, I'd have to disagree with that statement. At least slightly.
It's because of the addition of limited-slips and especially lockers that the 31 spline has become such a popular upgrade for Broncos.
While you can see that some here have had good luck so far with theirs, others have broken axles just playing around.
Only time will tell of course, but keep it in mind when you're running around off road.

Hi, as mentioned, you have the biggest most heavy duty stock Ford rear end of it's day.

They did actually offer 31 spline axles as stock on some models though. Just not EB's.
The big cars with big engines and tall gearing got them, as well as optional on some full-size trucks.

At least that's what I remember. Don't know if it was just some years, or if they were available all along.

Paul
 

Rustytruck

Bronco Guru
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
10,872
I think and automatic transmission is much easier on the axles too than driving a stick. I also find if you are using traction aids then getting the truck in 4wd as soon as possible off road will take off allot of load off a single axle being driven with a locker. A detroit locker driving the rear axles with no help from an unlocked front axle will be putting all the load on one axle as a rear tire slips. Any thing you can do to keep the rear from hopping as you struggle up a steep trail is a very wise move.

I never understood the mentality of people who brag I have a locker in the rear and drove the whole trail in 2wd I didn't need 4wd.

Anyone can break something every time. But the better way to go is to drive smart and careful so you don't break something every time. These trucks and their components are old and fatigue life comes to play. All of our trucks are on borrowed time.
 

blubuckaroo

Grease Monkey
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
11,796
Loc.
Ridgefield WA
I think and automatic transmission is much easier on the axles too than driving a stick. I also find if you are using traction aids then getting the truck in 4wd as soon as possible off road will take off allot of load off a single axle being driven with a locker. A detroit locker driving the rear axles with no help from an unlocked front axle will be putting all the load on one axle as a rear tire slips. Any thing you can do to keep the rear from hopping as you struggle up a steep trail is a very wise move.

I never understood the mentality of people who brag I have a locker in the rear and drove the whole trail in 2wd I didn't need 4wd.

Anyone can break something every time. But the better way to go is to drive smart and careful so you don't break something every time. These trucks and their components are old and fatigue life comes to play. All of our trucks are on borrowed time.

I just hope mine outlives me.;)
 
Top