I replaced 2 other caps last night that were brittle and cracked. One fell apart when pulling it off it was all dried up.
Glad you changed those. An all too common issue these days. In fact, the any new ones you get are likely to last anywhere from 3mo to about 1yr. Probably no more than that.
If you can find some from the dealer, or relatively new-ish ones at a junkyard, I think you're better off.
Unfortunately this makes the old "bolt-in-the-hose" method seem the best route to take. At least the fuel rated hose lasts for a goodly long time still. But the rubber and plastic and poly caps seem to be made out of petroleum-susceptible stuff.
Top dead center is lined up with the #1 cylinder wire on my distributor
That's usually a method to just get close enough to start. But if it does not fire up right away, don't hesitate to rotate the distributor by hand until it does. If you have a timing light, using it immediately would be a good thing.
And for all this, leaving the clamp bolt semi loose for now might be a good thing.
...and the cap looks good on the inside.
I'm not sure I agree. Maybe no visible cracks or failing bits, but it sure looks well used and carbon traced/scored in an unusual pattern.
I see you have the "small" Dura Spark cap and rotor still. Ford did not keep that for more than a year or so, until they upgraded to the "large" cap.
I would make a point that, if you're not going to replace it now, then the next time you need new plug wires, just replace the wires with the new style and replace the cap and rotor with the larger ones. You'll need the "cap-a-dapt" part, but it clips right on to your existing distributor using the stock clips.
You can buy them new just about anywhere I think, or score one in the junkyard.
But if it was me, and once I started it up if it runs rough like it needs a tune-up, I'd be replacing that cap and rotor even if with just the same style. Just looks pretty well used.
Did you clean the faces of the contacts while you were in there?